The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[AstrophelRose]

I'm really confused with this one due to sheer amount. Could someone give me some advice please?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98559914&userid=1013533&signature=G4XaB9lNJWb58pr2m2Fpcg

I'm not too fussed over the items being fair just the pets. Thanks in advance for any advice.

[employer]

hello !
could i get some help with this trade ?
i dont normally trade much haha
click me !

this is unfair to you using the 2:1 rule. your lion is a rerelease from 2009 <3

can i get any help on this trade?
i'm unsure on what the dog on their side is worth arhkesm
thank you in advance!!

this is unfair to the warrior cats. each warrior is worth ~3 '09 rares. their '08 rare should be worth 2 '09 rares

heya!! sorry to keep coming back here--
any help totally appreciated!

TRADE 1
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98571185&userid=723049&signature=pJqDekBnH34jrjQDZKRY3g

TRADE 2
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98536550&userid=723049&signature=YEskm5yILpBmR_nhN2m95A

TRADE 3
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98536857&userid=723049&signature=ZQsacJixAxzO03HtxyLqIg

help still needed <3

^^^ pls! <3

first trade:
your lions are technically worth about an '09 rare each, but a lot of the pets they offered have very poor demand due to being rats and butterflywolves, so i personally wouldn't accept this. especially since lions are always rather sought after

second trade:
sketch husky- 0.5 MA
2013 store dog- 1 MA

earth day deer- 1.5 MA

its a fair swap, but you'd probably be better off keeping the deer since it has very good demand

third trade:
tropical gryphon- 2 MA (somtimes a bit more due to being popular)
2015 store unicorn- ~0.5 MA
2008 VR- ~0.5 MA
total= ~3 MA

2015 store deer x2- 2 MA
earthday deer- 1.5 MA
total= 3.5 MA

unfair to you :C

[azazel.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98570776&userid=78983&signature=Cm99E0KnUXr2mfCaBhTkOA

would this be a fair trade qwq

still lookin qwq thanks in advance

[.:Infiniti:.]

as always tysm for the help!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98570023&userid=115466&signature=0oKTeXBuX79Smldp3HQZTA

bump :>

[employer]

as always tysm for the help!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98570023&userid=115466&signature=0oKTeXBuX79Smldp3HQZTA

bump :>

their side= ~4 '09 rares

your side= 3 '09 rares

this is slightly unfair to them imo <3

[winx]

Is this fair? I’m really bad at values ;v;’

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98567662&userid=949397&signature=8zafieBH9EV-I-j2gjJQjQ

Can someone please help? I’m sorry to bother

Sure! Here's what I found.

Their side
- "liver-spotted dalmation" = worth 3 month rule or 2 09 rares, also has equal/similar value to pets that turned very rare in january 2019
- "Spotted Tribal cat" = worth 3 month rule or 2 09 rares, but typically fetches more considering it is a non-warrior sitting cat. Has equal/similar value to pets that turned very rare in january 2019. Usually gets overpay of 3 09 rares.
- White/snowy phoenix (store pet, 2013 VR) - trade data showing this pet and its littermates trade for around ~0.5 MA each
- Black Calygreyhound (store pet, 2014 VR) - 0.5 MA, trade data here
- 2017 store pet valued at ~1 mid '09 rare
Total:
2 (dalmation) + 2-3 (sitting cat) + 1 (2017 store pet) = 5-6 09 rares
1 MA = 6-9 09 rares
~0.5 MA + 0.5 MA + 1 MA = ~2 MA (would be slightly under 2 MA if considering 2 rares for the sitting cat)

Your side
- Black Kitsune (store pet, 2013 VR) - trade data showing it goes for 1-2 MA, most recent trade in 2022 show it going for 2 MA. Tends to trade a bit higher than its other littermates
Total: 2 MA

So, overall, it can technically be considered fair.
However, unless you really like this trade, I personally wouldn't take it. It is essentially a trade down when you could get an equal or greater offer. The black kitsune has much better demand than the other pets they have offered. (:

[IZXY]

for my non td pink balloon dog'?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98571682&userid=726290&signature=grlmH7ZA9mPt7o2Yv4vEdw

[winx]

for my non td pink balloon dog'?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98571682&userid=726290&signature=grlmH7ZA9mPt7o2Yv4vEdw

Taken from an earlier post on this thread...

the TD skeleton PPS is an incredibly common TD since a huge hoard of them was recently disbanded. i'd value it at .25-.5

Pink balloon consistently gets 0.5 non and has way better demand.
Unfair to your side in my opinion.

[valkyrie,,]

hello! i have two trades i'd like some help on. trade 1; '16 store pet for '09 lion. trade 2; july pps. thank you!!

[IZXY]

for my pink balloon dog?
new trd

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98571857