The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Neoncherry64]

Does the additional common adjust the value of the top to fit the 3-month rule?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98492316&userid=5378&signature=ukAPw-Wxa4UdQQnXjxCw8A

It mostly depends on personal preference/how you value date differences, but I’d say this looks pretty fair.

[Pyca]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98468312&userid=933497&signature=4RJFG7K0fEP9dQ1dYTFWkQ

any help is appreciated, thank you

[puppi-kat]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98468312&userid=933497&signature=4RJFG7K0fEP9dQ1dYTFWkQ

any help is appreciated, thank you

using 2:1, your side is worth 2 '09 Rares. So it seems fair, but I find the guinea pigs do have some sort of a demand, where the rats usually don't. Definitely up to you on which side you prefer

[Pyca]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98468312&userid=933497&signature=4RJFG7K0fEP9dQ1dYTFWkQ

any help is appreciated, thank you

using 2:1, your side is worth 2 '09 Rares. So it seems fair, but I find the guinea pigs do have some sort of a demand, where the rats usually don't. Definitely up to you on which side you prefer

Thank you for the feed back!

[lamplighterB612]

Which bid of items is more fair?
1. this + add?

or

2. this?

Please help ASAP!

Also, is this fair?

[Rainyli]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=98493298&userid=897758&signature=oYDrJNmTkDFEzxewaQG9KQ

Their side: 2018 store pet
My side: 2010 rare, 2020 rare, an uncommon, and a plushie item

[Rbpuppy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98468312&userid=933497&signature=4RJFG7K0fEP9dQ1dYTFWkQ

any help is appreciated, thank you

using 2:1, your side is worth 2 '09 Rares. So it seems fair, but I find the guinea pigs do have some sort of a demand, where the rats usually don't. Definitely up to you on which side you prefer

I second this! Though it is fair rarity wise with 8 2011 Rares equaling a 2009 VR, Guinea pigs have higher demand than rats making them more valuable. I find the older Guinea pigs especially have higher demand so I’d personally keep your piggys c:

[Pyca]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98493533&userid=933497&signature=MSASNC5wum0Pc2EGdahFSQ

I got a second huge bulk trade for my guinea pigs xwx thanks for any feed back

((also thank you Rbpuppy for the last post!))

[eppi]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98476640&userid=793623&signature=IB7aj77vuQkdot0syROL6Q

Is this fair?? I don’t feel like it is?

[Dreams of Roses]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98476640&userid=793623&signature=IB7aj77vuQkdot0syROL6Q

Is this fair?? I don’t feel like it is?

2021 store pets are said to go for a late 2010 rare
your side is 2 early 2011 rares which would be an early 2010 rare with 2:1 rule, so it's not really fair