The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[JayJay]

Hello, can anybody help me with this trade
Thank you

Also this trade?

And this trade?

Thank you in advance

[♥HazelNightmare]

The trade was changed and now I’m wanting to check if this is fair! I do really want to accept this but I’ve got to double check to make sure it’s fair for both of us and no one is under or over paying (:

I’ll check for replies tomorrow, I need to sleep ♥️ Goodnight everyone !
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98466070&userid=997058&signature=faRqovpP-40WE7Q2Af2-bg

Keyword: blub (so I can find the post again)

It’s a solid offer

The Phoenix goes for 1.5-2 higher end likely x x x

The Strawberry 1.5 x

.5 additional would be 1,000-1,200 c$ x

[winx]

The trade was changed and now I’m wanting to check if this is fair! I do really want to accept this but I’ve got to double check to make sure it’s fair for both of us and no one is under or over paying (:

I’ll check for replies tomorrow, I need to sleep ♥️ Goodnight everyone !
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98466070&userid=997058&signature=faRqovpP-40WE7Q2Af2-bg

Keyword: blub (so I can find the post again)

Your side
UR Phoenix [ranges from 1.5-2 non] ~ Depends on how you and your partner value the Phoenix. Some consider it to be closer to 1.5 non due to a lower demand and an unpopular species. Others believe a true date pushes it closer to the 2 non range, but this is entirely up to if you value true dates more than re-releases. It appears your partner is valuing the Phoenix as 2 nons
Total: 1.5-2 nons
Trade data ~ varies between 1.5~2 nons

Their side
UR Strawb. Cake [~1.5 non]
1000 C$ [~0.5 non]
Total: 2 nons
Trade data ~ consistently at 1.5 nons

Thus, it is fair in my opinion!

C$ guide here
Horrors list here

[Flicka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97073216&userid=9355&signature=Lv0nT9pD-S7YgNf-Dw-ztA is this fair?

[Octopia]

two Nick horses for Raver bun

[MewSefet]

is this fair?

Slight overpay for the husky. The mini Husky is valued at 1 MA (7-8 09R), with their side working out to be just over 9x09R using the 2:1 rule

The trade was changed and now I’m wanting to check if this is fair! I do really want to accept this but I’ve got to double check to make sure it’s fair for both of us and no one is under or over paying (:

I’ll check for replies tomorrow, I need to sleep ♥️ Goodnight everyone !
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98466070&userid=997058&signature=faRqovpP-40WE7Q2Af2-bg

Keyword: blub (so I can find the post again)

From what I can find both the UR shortcake and UR phoenix are both trading at 1.5 non at the moment, so this would be unfair to the strawberry. The UR phoenix can trade up to 2non, so if you are valuing at 2 non, the 0.5 non difference would be made up with the C$ which apparently is C$1000 at the moment, but I'm not sure how realistic that is (back in my day 1 non = C$1200 x.x)

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98465973&userid=987164&signature=3DWezrgqhTm6SV14WAysrg Is this one good? (srry for all the question i do NOT know cs worths work for anything remotely valuable)

Very unfair to the store pets I believe!

I'm not super amazing with items, so get a second opinion, but heres what I've found:
Striped Pink September (dog) = 2MA (14-16 x09R)
Christmas PJ Pants = 1x 2010 UC
Target = 1x 2011 UC
Vampire Hat, Mouse Family (4), Crimson Rose Pin, Belted Leather Boots= 1x 2012 UCea (7x 2012 UC TOTAL)
Easter Egg = 1x 2013 UC
Item total (using 2:1 rule for years) = 0.42x 09R
TOTAL= 14.42 to 16.42x 09R

4x 2012 Store Pets (1MA each) = 4MA (28-32 x09R)
TOTAL= 28-32 x09R

Hello, can anybody help me with this trade
Thank you

Also this trade?

And this trade?

Thank you in advance

UR Galaxy cat = 1.5n

Trade 1:
UR Bwolf= 1.25n
Robo cat + Unicorn = 0.5MAea (1MA)
Deer = 1MA
TOTAL= just under 1.5n

Trade 2:
UR Flower pot= 1n
Deer = 1MA
Pink September = 2MA
PPS Cocoon = 1 MA
Santa cat = 1 MA
Blackstar= 1 MA
TOTAL=1.5non

Trade 3:
Robo cat = 0.5MA
UR Foal = 1-1.5n (trading towards 1non)
TOTAL= between 1 and 1.5 non

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98465627&userid=669255&signature=Oycv01WOOKmFbK7EdjE1qA

Opinions??

Just under on the cake dog side if valuing the rat at 0.25non

Cake dog = 2-3MA
Leopardstar = 2-3x 09R

toxic flower rat= 0.25-0.5non

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97073216&userid=9355&signature=Lv0nT9pD-S7YgNf-Dw-ztA is this fair?

Unfair to the horse
Horse = 2x 09R
Bulk- 1.2x 09R (based off 2:1 rules)

two Nick horses for Raver bun

Unfair to the bunny I believe. Couldn't find much info re nick horses though

Raver Bunny=1MA (7-8x 09R)

Nick horses = 2x09R each = 4x 09R total

[Frozen_Cherry]

Help is appreciated!! trades/viewtrade.php?id=98466461&userid=725461&signature=MLV8IwTa6sMeeAM5uD38SA

[Jacklin009]

So I have a couple trades that I am unsure of. I am uncertain how much some of the very rare pets are actually worth. I feel like I am a bit biased when it comes to the Malk pets, such as the heart dog/fox from valentines day. I don't want to make a trade unfair because I feel like my pet is worth a lot more than it actually is.

Any help or suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98447988&userid=70184&signature=-A5_co6g-D08zsOnaB1I4Q

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98447948&userid=70184&signature=e1pYwPkXmmAHxJHcKnHBuQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98448000&userid=70184&signature=9c127FGpFMFx-zA74zdiUw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98447930&userid=70184&signature=6q7KspEy875XhcTZboIHdg

[.star.]

Hey everyone!! I need some help tyyy!!


trades/viewtrade.php?id=98466779&userid=725429&signature=LMrRrXc80whdA8wH_J8Jqw

[MewSefet]

Help is appreciated!! trades/viewtrade.php?id=98466461&userid=725461&signature=MLV8IwTa6sMeeAM5uD38SA

Reasonably fair I believe, I do think demand favours the store + warrior cat side


2012 April Fools Butterdog= 0.5 to 1MA
2x 2009R
1x2009VR (can't find anything specific re this rat)
2x 2010R
2x 2012R
TOTAL=8.25 to 13.25 x09R

Boreyne Store Dog (2013)= 0.5 to 1MA (I've seen them more towards the 0.5 MA)
Jaypaw= 2-3x 09R
TOTAL= 9-11x 09R