The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[LiLi041]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98461940&userid=536230&signature=r46xrxbOidh85PDQmOgQhw

help pls, i'm bad when it comes to warrior cat rarities

Big overpay on their side imo, rare warrior cats are generally worth 3 '09s. Their side has much more than just 3, and even if you use the higher value of 0.5 MA or 3.5 '09s, their side still has more than that.

[lamplighterB612]

Which bid of items is more fair?
1. this + add?

or

2. this?

Please help ASAP!

Also, is this fair?

[abbie.]

any help with this trade
am i better off with my side?
thank you in advance!! <3

[BlueCottonCandy]

Hello! would this be a fair trade for me? trades/viewtrade.php?id=98452865&userid=687800&signature=Mv3UuPRGP7WPFiOpng11Og

[winx]

any help with this trade
am i better off with my side?
thank you in advance!! <3

Rare warrior cats are generally worth 3 09' rares.

On their side, they have:
1 09' rare
2 2011 rares = 1 2010 rare
2 2022 store pets = 2 ~late 2010 rares (this is an estimate based on 2021 store pet values since 2022 store pets are still fluctuating) = 1 ~late 2009 rare
Total equivalent to: 2 2009 rares + 1 2010 rare... which is underpay
You're better off with your side for the underpay and also ponies have particularly low demand, so you could probably do a lot better.

[winx]

Hello! would this be a fair trade for me? trades/viewtrade.php?id=98452865&userid=687800&signature=Mv3UuPRGP7WPFiOpng11Og

7 2011 rares = 3 2010 rares + 1 extra 2011 rare
3 2010 rares = 1 2009 rare + 1 extra 2010 rare
Total: 1 2009 rare + 1 extra 2010 rare + 1 extra 2011 rare for your 1 2009 rare

Technically it is fair in my opinion if you are fine with trading down. Other options would include waiting for a trade that fits the three month rule for a neutral trade (1 09' rare for 1 09' rare) or waiting to trade up.

[pebblick]

help me please?

[Noobieclean]

i would like some help with this, cuz im a bit new to how fair the trades are

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98462740&userid=1000694&signature=LpUqUq6MD9XYZO9VkRprMA

[cupidtwn]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98462753&userid=898252&signature=so3xPyUUKbokUK47b4A9zQ is this fair?

[BlueCottonCandy]

Hello! would this be a fair trade for me? trades/viewtrade.php?id=98452865&userid=687800&signature=Mv3UuPRGP7WPFiOpng11Og

7 2011 rares = 3 2010 rares + 1 extra 2011 rare
3 2010 rares = 1 2009 rare + 1 extra 2010 rare
Total: 1 2009 rare + 1 extra 2010 rare + 1 extra 2011 rare for your 1 2009 rare

Technically it is fair in my opinion if you are fine with trading down. Other options would include waiting for a trade that fits the three month rule for a neutral trade (1 09' rare for 1 09' rare) or waiting to trade up.

Thank you so much!