The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[xephtyr]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98334315&userid=1020576&signature=B5E2_2IcQWhi0dkECxhBfA
Hello would this be fair for the persons warrior cats? I was told that rare warrior cats were only worth 2-3 '09 rares, so I'm a little worried I might be overpaying a little? Thank you in advance!

[Strawberry_dreams]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98334315&userid=1020576&signature=B5E2_2IcQWhi0dkECxhBfA
Hello would this be fair for the persons warrior cats? I was told that rare warrior cats were only worth 2-3 '09 rares, so I'm a little worried I might be overpaying a little? Thank you in advance!

The VR warriors are 1MA and the grinners are 2MA do this is unfair to you if you take off the second grinner and add 2-3 ‘09 rares it will be fair
The rare warriors are 2-3’09 rare and the VR ones are 1MA

[da,]

BIG LIST TRADE pls only answer if you're sure, I'm sorry ; ^ ;

TD GWJ, TD Dogtag, TD Red Toxic, TD Sunback

for

UR Avocado, Clockwork Bun, UR Squid, UR PPS Dragon, Sock Dog, Purple Tess Dragon

I know TD's are technically worth the same on paper, but they can fetch more, and I am willing to pay a little more, so feel free to calculate this taking truedates into consideration or not, either way is fine <3 Thank you for your time!

I'm not too sure how TDs values work so i'll be going by basic demand value;

GWJ (1n) + dogtag (1.5-2n) + red toxic (.25-.5n) + sunback (3-3.5n) = 5.75n-7n
UR avo (.5-1n) + clockwork bun (1.5n) + ur squid (.5-1n) + pps malk dragon (1.5n) + sock dog (2-3 MA) = 4n + 4ish MA-5n + 4ish MA

either way it seems pretty unfair to the sunback side

[gunthyr]

BIG LIST TRADE pls only answer if you're sure, I'm sorry ; ^ ;

TD GWJ, TD Dogtag, TD Red Toxic, TD Sunback

for

UR Avocado, Clockwork Bun, UR Squid, UR PPS Dragon, Sock Dog, Purple Tess Dragon

I know TD's are technically worth the same on paper, but they can fetch more, and I am willing to pay a little more, so feel free to calculate this taking truedates into consideration or not, either way is fine <3 Thank you for your time!

I'm not too sure how TDs values work so i'll be going by basic demand value;

GWJ (1n) + dogtag (1.5-2n) + red toxic (.25-.5n) + sunback (3-3.5n) = 5.75n-7n
UR avo (.5-1n) + clockwork bun (1.5n) + ur squid (.5-1n) + pps malk dragon (1.5n) + sock dog (2-3 MA) = 4n + 4ish MA-5n + 4ish MA

either way it seems pretty unfair to the sunback side

agreed. given the values without considering that their side is true dates, additionally considering that would make it even more unfair for their side.
i believe a td red toxic is 0.75n, a td sunback potentially 7+ nons. im not sure about the gwj or dogtag, but even if you removed all pets but the sunback, it'd still be under by a considerable amount.

[test.tube.bunny]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98334637&userid=916513&signature=dZLGDKmSBLMbYei12NJojQ

was i better off accepting this or no?

[240SX]

can anyone let me know if this is fair:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98333932&userid=536230&signature=rsBNjLGEUkTeTxACMh1Wbw

[Corey Taylor]

Is this fair for my space rat?

[Wind]

Opinions?

[Jiloon]

Opinions?

Unfair to you, the Christmas Tree Dog is worth 1ma and fetches that, the Hyena Advent goes for 1.5-2MA easily

[Howl's Moving Castle]

BIG LIST TRADE pls only answer if you're sure, I'm sorry ; ^ ;

TD GWJ, TD Dogtag, TD Red Toxic, TD Sunback

for

UR Avocado, Clockwork Bun, UR Squid, UR PPS Dragon, Sock Dog, Purple Tess Dragon

I know TD's are technically worth the same on paper, but they can fetch more, and I am willing to pay a little more, so feel free to calculate this taking truedates into consideration or not, either way is fine <3 Thank you for your time!

I'm not too sure how TDs values work so i'll be going by basic demand value;

GWJ (1n) + dogtag (1.5-2n) + red toxic (.25-.5n) + sunback (3-3.5n) = 5.75n-7n
UR avo (.5-1n) + clockwork bun (1.5n) + ur squid (.5-1n) + pps malk dragon (1.5n) + sock dog (2-3 MA) = 4n + 4ish MA-5n + 4ish MA

either way it seems pretty unfair to the sunback side

agreed. given the values without considering that their side is true dates, additionally considering that would make it even more unfair for their side.
i believe a td red toxic is 0.75n, a td sunback potentially 7+ nons. im not sure about the gwj or dogtag, but even if you removed all pets but the sunback, it'd still be under by a considerable amount.

this is unfair to the TD side, TD GWJ can go for anywhere around 2-2.5, TD dogtag is at least 2-2.5 nons, TD toxic .75 and TD sunback is 4+ depending on date. the math for your side has already been calculated. i suggest telling them the worths of their pets and working out a fair trade to them.