The “How much is this pet worth?” Thread!

[Kira C-137]

Hi does anyone know anything about this bunny?

[ahirked]

Hi does anyone know anything about this bunny?

the snow bunny is a 2009 Christmas release, and is worth a regular 2009 rare within the 3-month rule <:

[Smokeyman4ever!]

. How much is this cute set worth its from august 2010

Bump

Bump

[latias.]

Kinda a broad question, how much is an entire store pet collection worth? I think I want to try my hand at obtaining every store pet ever released.

[Lennie]

EDIT 07/05/22: as it has been a few months since the store pets list below was updated, please take some of the older pet values with a grain of salt as they can fluctuate over time.
I have every intention of creating an updated list at some point in the future. ^^

. How much is this cute set worth its from august 2010

Every outcome in this litter is worth the three month rule, with the potential demand-influence exception of the PeaPS outcome. While the outcome first turned very rare in the 2019 rarity update x and by rarity is technically only worth the three month rule, there are limited successful trades to suggest the pet is capable of fetching up to 1 MA x x in the most extreme of cases. Please do note that limited trades are not reflective of an inherent trend, but it's goo to keep in mind as you will likely find people who value the outcome somewhere within the range of the three month rule and the higher successful trade values.

Kinda a broad question, how much is an entire store pet collection worth? I think I want to try my hand at obtaining every store pet ever released.

This is going to be quite a long response, but I'm going to bulk together some years of outcomes and I will be treating very rare & rare store pets to be the same if they are from the same year, as general trading trends suggest there is limited difference between the two values when it comes to store pets. Exceptions will exist to this as some pet outcomes are distinctly sought after and have inflated demand value.
I will be breaking down the values by year total (based on successful trading evidence for valuing), before doing a final total. These aren't firm values and are estimations based on successful trade values/common trade values!
A complete list of store pets through 2021 can be found here.

2009

• Skelebun - 12-15+ nons (general trend suggests ~15 nons) x
• Orange Cerberus - 10-12 nons (general trend suggests ~10 nons x x
• Drink Me - ~6 nons x
• Eat Me - ~5 nons x
• Green Liontail - 2.5-3 nons (general trend suggests ~3 nons) x
• Jeweled Liontail - 2.5-3 nons (general trend suggests ~3 nons) x
• Nonjeweled Liontail - ~3 nons x
  
  2009 Total: ~45 nons
  ---
  
  2010
• Red Seal PPS - 0.75 nons x
• Blue Seal PPS - 0.5-0.75 nons (general trend suggests closer to ~0.75 nons) x
• Green Seal PPS - 0.75 nons (limited trade evidence on its own) x
• Red Cerberus - 4.5-5 nons (settling ~5 nons lately) x x
• Brown Sleipnir - 2.5-3 nons (more consistently ~3 nons) x
• Blue / Yellow / Red Android - 0.5 nons each / total of 1.5 nons x
• Green Android - ~1 non x
• Orange / Pink / Yellow Punk - 0.5 nons each / total of 1.5 nons x
• Lolita - 1-1.5 nons (generally ~1.5 nons lately) x
• Patchwork - ~1.5 nons (most consistently valued here, may be valued up to 2 nons) x
• Raven - 4-5+ nons (most consistently ~5 nons) x
• Marionette - ~2 nons x
• Clockwork Bun - ~1.5 nons x
  
  2010 Total: ~25.25 nons
  ---
  
  2011
• Clydesdale - 0.25-0.5 nons x
• White / Bay / Chestnut Arabian Horse - 0.25-0.5 nons each / total of 0.75-1.5 nons (the set seems to settle at ~1.25 nons) x
• Angry / Shy or Tan / Brown Basilisk - ~0.25 nons each / total of 0.75 nons x
• Lava / Ice / Tropical / Forest or Moss Gryphon - ~2 MAs each / total of 8 MAs x
• Lionfish / Green Spotted Mandarin / Betta / Arapaima Seahorse - ~2 MAs each / total of 8 MAs x
• Summer Forest / Autumn Forest / Spring Forest Guardian - ~2 MAs each / total of 8 MAs x
• Brown / Grey / Zebra / White Carousel Horse - ~2 MAs each / total of 8 MAs x
  
  2011 Total: 2.25-2.5 nons + 32 MAs = ~5.25-5.5 nons
  --
  
  2012
• Blue / Green / Pink / Purple Alien Dog - ~1 MA each / total of 4 MAs x
• Black/Purple / Cream/Blue / Brown / Green/Yellow - ~1 MA each / total of 4 MAs x
• Brown Kirin / Orange Kirin / Fire Unicorn / Black Rainbow Unicorn - ~1 MA each / total of 4 MAs x x x
• Black / Pink / Blue / Green Fairy Goat - ~1 MA each / total of 4 MAs x
• Brown / Spotted / Floppy Jackalope - ~1 MA each / total of 3 MAs x
• Bandersnatch / Jabberwocky / Jubjub Bird - ~1 MA each / total of 3 MAs x x x
• Cheshire Cat - ~0.25+ nons or 3 MAs (there is a relatively wide valuing range for this specific outcome) x
  
  2012 Total: ~2+ nons or 25 MAs
  ---
  
  2013
• Theow / Nemean Lion / Chimera / Boreyne Dog - ~0.5-1 MA each / total of 2-4 MAs x x x
  (^ loosely - there is very little trade data for these outcomes, so this value is skewed by the limited data)
• White/Snowy / Green/Leafy / Red/Fiery / Blue/Starry Phoenix - ~0.5 MAs each / total of 2 MAs x
• Black Spotted / Pink Spotted / White / Light Brown / Dark Brown Alpaca [Llama] - ~1 MA each / total of 4 MAs x x
• Bead/Spell Tag / Jade Coin / Sakura / Black/Fire Kitsune Mask - ~1-2+ MAs each / total of 4-8 MAs x
• Leaf / Spiderweb / Frost / Snow Fairy Rat - ~1 MA each / total of 4 MAs (limited trade data) x
• Blue Merle / Tricolour / Red / Rainbow Corgi [storgi] - ~1+ MA each / total of 4 MAs (minimum common value) x
  
  2013 Total: ~1.5-2 nons or 20-26 MAs
  ---
  
  2014
• Lava / Lilac / Green / Orange / PPS Kirin/Koi - 0.5 MA each / total of 2 MAs x
• Brown / Orange / Cream / Black Calygreyhound - 0.5 MA each / total of 2 MAs x
• White / Blue / Black Robo-Cat [Robot Cat] - 0.5 MA each / total of 1.5 MAs x x
• Orange / Calico Goldfish Dog - 0.5 MA each / total of 1 MA x
• Origami Star Dog - 0.5-1 MA x
• Cherry Blossom/Sakura Dog - ~1 MA x x
• Fire / Earth / Water Dragon Cat - ~0.5 MA each / total of ~1.5 MAs x
  (^ limited trade data - pps outcome comes up more often)
• PPS Dragon Cat - ~0.25+ nons or ~3-4+ MAs x x x
• Pitbull / Weimeraner / Old English Sheepdog / Borzoi - ~0.5+ MAs each / total of ~2 MAs x x x x
  
  2014 Total: ~1.25 nons or 14.5-16 MAs
  ---
  
  2015
• Galaxy / Frosty/Furry / Storm/Lightning / Cupcake Unicorn - ~0.5 MAs each / total of 2 MA (limited specific trade data) x
• Rainbow Pegasis - ~0.5 MAs (limited specific trade data, same as above) x
• Oil Spill / Mother Nature / Crystal/Rock / Broken World / Earth Day Deer - ~0.5-1 MA each / total of 2.5-5 MA x x
• Red / Aqua / Blue / Yellow/Green / Purple Dragon PPS - ~2 '09 rares each / total of 10 '09 rares (limited specific trade data) x
• Raccoon / RingTailed Lemur / Red Panda / Skunk - ~2-3 '09 rares to 0.5 MA each / total of 8-12 '09 rares to 2 MA x x x
• Brown / YinYang / Fire / Blue/Ice Manticore Lion - ~2 '09 rares each / total of 8 '09 rares x
• PPS Manticore Lion - ~2+ '09 rares (very limited specific trade data for specific outcome, much higher value listed as well) x
• Black / Cream / Magenta / Pink Halo B-Wolf - ~2 '09 rares each / total of 8 '09 rares
  (^ no specific trade data listed, valuing based on commonly cited values for 2015 store pets)
  
  2015 Total: ~5 MAs + 36-40 '09 rares (4-6.5 MAs) = ~9-11.5 MAs
  ---
  
  For 2016 and forward, excluding special exceptions (notable inflated demand value), I will be totaling how many store pets there are in the year and then averaging based on commonly accepted/cited values for store pets in this thread.
  
  2016
• PPS Pegicorn/Unicorn may fetch slightly more as a product of demand, but the successful trade data was limited.
  Total number of 2016 store pets: 26
  2016 store pet valued at ~1 early '09 rare
  2016 Total: 26 (early) '09 rares
  
  2017
• PPS Gryphin [Gryphon] and PPS Fairy Fennec may fetch slightly more as a product of demand, but successful trade data was limited.
  Total number of 2017 store pets: 26
  2017 store pet valued at ~1 mid '09 rare
  2017 Total: 26 (mid) '09 rares
  
  2018
  I am omitting the value of the item set that was included with the Punk Store Dragons.
  Total number of 2018 store pets: 26
  2018 store pet valued at ~1 late '09 rare
  2018 Total: 26 (late) '09 rares
  
  2019
  Total number of 2019 store pets: 29
  2019 store pet valued at ~1 early '10 rare
  2019 Total: 29 (early) '10 rares
  
  2020
  Total number of 2020 store pets: 25
  2020 store pet valued at ~1 mid '10 rare
  2020 Total: 25 (mid) '10 rares
  
  2021
  Total number of 2021 store pets: 30
  2021 store pet valued at ~1 late '10 rare
  2021 Total: 30 (late) '10 rares
  
  I will be omitting 2022 store pets for this totaling, as there has only been 1 store set so far and the rarity for the outcomes have not been noted.
  For ease of totaling the estimation, I will also be valuing 2 '10 rares = 1 '09 rare (which I recognize is not a set value and not everyone utilizes rarity math).
  Following the above math parameters: 2016-2021 totals ~120 '09 rares or ~1 non
  
  OVERALL TOTAL (very rough estimation):
  ~82.25-83 nons
  
  ---
  I apologize if my totaling math is a little off on this, I used the valuing found here (in the Condensed Rarity List) and may have gotten a little muddled with the sheer amount of data listed ^^;;

[fiasco]

hi! still hoping to find out what the 2015 store manticore set is worth x
thinking of auctioning them off but I’m not sure what they’re really worth/what a decent auto to set would be ^^

[jettabar99]

what is the 2009 Mime GUPPS worth please?

[walks223]

hi! still hoping to find out what the 2015 store manticore set is worth x
thinking of auctioning them off but I’m not sure what they’re really worth/what a decent auto to set would be ^^

i believe ive seen them go for 0.5MA each but please correct me if i'm wrong!
so that would be around 2.5MA + some demand for the pps <3

[Smokeyman4ever!]

Hi i was wondering if this baby


Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!

And this baby


Pet's name: Chocolate Ice Cream Rat
Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!

Are worth a omgsr

Let me get the other pet

[latias.]

Hi i was wondering if this baby


Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!

And this baby


Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!

Are worth a omgsr

Let me get the other pet

Nope, sorry. They're worth the three-month rule.