The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Geckos_N_Tea]

uh, wouldn't this be a little unfair(/fair if this is enough bulk to be 'valued more') for my 2009 dog? it got cancelled rather rudely with no message which makes me a bit anxious about any of the cats being something special hbshbshbshbs

I'd say it's fair to overpay on your side, but they may just be one of those people who values bulk more than the average person. I'm sorry about the rude message!

i’m not sure if the cat on their side is a warrior or not which could make it unfair to their side, and even if not some ppl value sitting cats a bit higher than normal rares. and i’m also sorry about the rude message, i hate when people send those! ):

[2b2t]

uh, wouldn't this be a little unfair(/fair if this is enough bulk to be 'valued more') for my 2009 dog? it got cancelled rather rudely with no message which makes me a bit anxious about any of the cats being something special hbshbshbshbs

I'd say it's fair to overpay on your side, but they may just be one of those people who values bulk more than the average person. I'm sorry about the rude message!

i’m not sure if the cat on their side is a warrior or not which could make it unfair to their side, and even if not some ppl value sitting cats a bit higher than normal rares. and i’m also sorry about the rude message, i hate when people send those! ):

it isn't a warrior which is why i'm so confused, it's only one of the 2010 ragdolls.
thank you two regardless

[phxyvi]

I'd say it's fair to overpay on your side, but they may just be one of those people who values bulk more than the average person. I'm sorry about the rude message!

i’m not sure if the cat on their side is a warrior or not which could make it unfair to their side, and even if not some ppl value sitting cats a bit higher than normal rares. and i’m also sorry about the rude message, i hate when people send those! ):

it isn't a warrior which is why i'm so confused, it's only one of the 2010 ragdolls.
thank you two regardless

Sometimes it is less being fair and more being favorable ^^ the trade wasn’t super favorable to them, the 09 has no particular demand and most people like the little short unc quite a bit. Even being not a warrior, the sitting cats are still desirable. As well as the interest in bulk rares that others have, when you get past a couple years- the 2:1 rule may be fair, but it is not favorable.

[Spottedleaf16]

How’s this one? I’m not used to trading with store pets so idk if it’s fair or who’s overpaying
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97947102&userid=234404&signature=KdlcQ4LIklKDIlARsV87Jg

[valkyrie,,]

hello! i have two item trades. this is the first one and this is the second. thanks!

[qhost]

Could I possibly have some opinions on this trade? I'm not good with item trades. ;~;

[Guest]

Could I possibly have some opinions on this trade? I'm not good with item trades. ;~;

Their side contains about .5n of items [monster eyes = .25, hammer = .25], although the hammer doesn't have the best demand.
I'd definitely prefer your side opposed to theirs.

[Leylard]

is this good? thank you so much!! <33

i need help with this one too!

[( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°]

is this good? thank you so much!! <33

i need help with this one too!

Neither of those trades are fair at all.

The first one is trying to swap two 2019 store pets for 2016 ones? Thats extremely unfair, plus the pps lion is way high up in demand and both of those stores pet probably wouldn't be fair for it

The second one doesn't even add up close to those store pets, plus again for the PPS lions they can get more since there high up in demand. I wouldn't accept either of those

[Neoncherry64]

How’s this one? I’m not used to trading with store pets so idk if it’s fair or who’s overpaying
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97947102&userid=234404&signature=KdlcQ4LIklKDIlARsV87Jg

Each store cat is generally worth a late 2010 rare. The 2009 on their side is equal to two of your cats, it is up to you if a low demand 2012 rare + 15c$ is equal to a 2010 in your mind. It is up to you!

Looking at the c$ chart (which to be fair is a bit outdated) it seems like this could be fair for the low end of a 2010 rare. It really comes down to which side you personally prefer.