The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[far]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97914745&userid=631842&signature=Jn_Ct4zVNTYVwJiX2aJOiw
Could I get some help with the value of these items?

[Tea...]

Is this fair? I sent it with just the aussie and my sister said it was fair but they sent it back saying that this is more fair for demand?
I just want another opinion thank you <3
the trade

[lemon.shark]

Is this fair for the 08 bat winged dog?
If not, what would make it fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97907795&userid=24501&signature=PPNkggMmW-rpyFN3maE_OA

Bumping for my trade partner

Okay, so according to Horror's list, the Bat dog goes for about 2-3 MA.

On the other side of the the trade here are the fruits of my research:
- Nick Sunback = 3 09 rares (little less than .5 MA)
- Nick Tox = 3 09 rares (little less than .5 MA)
- Green Striped Rat = ~1 MA, but low demand so maybe less.
- Purple Star Bobtail = 1 MA

Also notable information: 1 MA = ~6-9 09 rares.

The pets listed above are the only ones included on the list, and I'm not qualified to say how much the others are worth. However, these four do add up to about 2.5-2.75 MA, maybe? So do with that what you will, and happy trading :)

[Lanayru]

Would this be fair? We're unsure if the Gray Dutch bun is 1 or 2 MA and wanna make it fair for both sides - TYSM in advance!

unfair to you
the blue light stripe is worth 1 ma, and so is the bun
there is no need for the 0.5 ma add

Tysm! Would it be possible to get a 2nd opinion to be safe? :-]

[Mother]

Would this trade be fair? The item is 1MA if I remember correctly but I also want to know if well, it has good demand and make sure if it's fair-

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97914632&userid=943439&signature=3H3uPRraIfvPYk6B-IKMJA

[Fennelroot]

Is this fair? I sent it with just the aussie and my sister said it was fair but they sent it back saying that this is more fair for demand?
I just want another opinion thank you <3
the trade

Unfair to you.

The Evil PPS is 1 MA, the Seal PPS is 0.75 nons and the Gryphon dog is 2 MA.

Your side is 1 MA per butterfly wolf, 1.5 MA for the kitsune and 0.75-1 non for the Aussie.

Even at the lowest value for your aussie (which has good demand) you're still 0.5 MA over.

Would this trade be fair? The item is 1MA if I remember correctly but I also want to know if well, it has good demand and make sure if it's fair-

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97914632&userid=943439&signature=3H3uPRraIfvPYk6B-IKMJA

They are overpaying by adding the 2012 dog as the item is 1 MA. Items in general don't have great demand though.

[abbie.]

could i get an opinion on these trades?
x
(non-ballon for merle corgi, light leopard & blue rose)

x
(various rares & some c$ for blue rose)

i’m 99% sure the first one is fair but i just wanted to double check it, unsure about the second one though
thank you in advance!!

[vukiyo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97915506&userid=960212&signature=Xd18LYXA2aScIzBsNFZB9Q

Would this be fair?

[Spacepvp]

Would this be fair? ;V;
X

[Fennelroot]

Would this be fair? ;V;
X

Their dog is worth 1 MA.

Your trade is worth 8 2009 rares, 1 MA is 6-9 '09 rares. Horses don't have amazing demand so this is fair, but you could probably get a better deal somewhere else (or if you used 3 VR 2009 dogs instead).

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97915506&userid=960212&signature=Xd18LYXA2aScIzBsNFZB9Q

Would this be fair?

Very unfair to you.

Pink Sorbet is worth 0.75 non.

The corgi is worth 1 MA and the Blue Rose Dog is worth 0.25 non.