The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[patriciaツ]

hi! i recently started playing again and know nothing about items, could i please get some help with this trade? thanks in advance! :) https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97913866&userid=573841&signature=B46Qt6Z-kutg4Uh6U8eXhg

[abbie.]

could i get an opinion on these trades?
x
(non-ballon for merle corgi, light leopard & blue rose)

x
(various rares & some c$ for blue rose)

i’m 99% sure the first one is fair but i just wanted to double check it, unsure about the second one though
thank you in advance!!

[Bellarocks123a]

hi! i recently started playing again and know nothing about items, could i please get some help with this trade? thanks in advance! https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97913866&userid=573841&signature=B46Qt6Z-kutg4Uh6U8eXhg

horsehair wig = anywhere from low demand '09-'11 uncommon/rare. the natural colours are more popular, but there seem to be different opinions regarding whether they should be uncommon or rare. (sources: 2010/2011 r; 09 r; 2011 uncommon or two; 2011 r).

Source

Not sure on the robe though. If there's no special demand on it, it would go for an UC pet from the same year. Didn't see anything from a first glance at the "How Much Is This Item Worth"? Thread or the previous thread that was remade when it got too long

[NoGoodDeed]

would you accept this?

or this?

trade 1 // the eat me dog trades for 5 - 5.5nons [from what i can find on this thread]. your side adds up to 5.5n - 6n depending how the dog tag is valued [1.5-2n]. the zonkey is 2n and the smore is 2n.
i'd get a second opinion here, as i'm not 100% sure on what the eat me goes for! i do know it had good demand though, and i don't think you'd have any trouble trading it off again if that's what you were going to do.

trade 2 // your side = 4 nons [ zonkey = 2n, smore = 2n]. their side adds up to 4n as well [non swirl = 1n, sunjewel = 3n] plus a few uncommons. it's a fair trade, so it's up to you and what you prefer c:

Thank you! May i have a second opinion please?

[crabs!]

any thoughts on this trade?

[parted]

I need your help with this one: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97913759&userid=632280&signature=BpP8-i4X54mv_k-60c15Ow

[luvbot]

Is this fair? Or am I better off keeping my pets for other trades, I don't know the demand of the cat so I'm unsure ^^'

[Ashara]

How does this look? I'm not sure how much the crescent moon or red glove items are worth.

[Mejibray]

Is this fair for the 08 bat winged dog?
If not, what would make it fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97907795&userid=24501&signature=PPNkggMmW-rpyFN3maE_OA

[Flicka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94078761&userid=9355&signature=41VxW5am7f9kSJLZQnSoiw is this fair?