The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[2b2t]

Would this be fair? I honestly want to know if the pets manage to make the deer store pet fair since I do know that the 2015 deer store pets have a good demand but I’m not completely sure- ^^

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97913127&userid=943439&signature=TZOsicoGk8Ogja2W11M1KA

2015 store pet, worth 2 '09 rares. unless there's very specific demand for any of these on their side (which i doubt) that adds up to this much, this isnt fair

[Rbpuppy]

i’d love some opinions on this trade!

this doesn't look fair using the 2:1 rule as the dragon itself is worth a mid '09 rare (being a 2017 store pet) and the pets themselves don't add up to that, unless there's some demand for any of the pets on their side. however i'd assume you could get a mid '09 rare and maybe more if you get the right person as these dragons are in demand as far as i know. ^^

I second this! It’s very unfair to your store pet c:

[erinfinn]

Is this fair? Or am I better off keeping my pets for other trades, I don't know the demand of the cat so I'm unsure ^^'

i believe this is unfair to you. the cheshire can get 2-3 ma. your TD GSD can get up to 1.5 ma, the deer 1 ma, sakura dog can is .5-1 ma i believe, robot cat im not entirely sure, maybe 1 la but don't quote me. i recommend a second opinion

Would this be fair? I honestly want to know if the pets manage to make the deer store pet fair since I do know that the 2015 deer store pets have a good demand but I’m not completely sure- ^^

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97913127&userid=943439&signature=TZOsicoGk8Ogja2W11M1KA

unfair to you, the deer can get 1 ma

[hayzel]

Would this be fair? I honestly want to know if the pets manage to make the deer store pet fair since I do know that the 2015 deer store pets have a good demand but I’m not completely sure- ^^

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97913127&userid=943439&signature=TZOsicoGk8Ogja2W11M1KA

2015 store pet, worth 2 '09 rares. unless there's very specific demand for any of these on their side (which i doubt) that adds up to this much, this isnt fair

the deer store pets can actually fetch 1ma [or 6-9 '09 rares] due to demand c:

[Mother]

Would this be fair? I honestly want to know if the pets manage to make the deer store pet fair since I do know that the 2015 deer store pets have a good demand but I’m not completely sure- ^^

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97913127&userid=943439&signature=TZOsicoGk8Ogja2W11M1KA

2015 store pet, worth 2 '09 rares. unless there's very specific demand for any of these on their side (which i doubt) that adds up to this much, this isnt fair

the deer store pets can actually fetch 1ma [or 6-9 '09 rares] due to demand c:

Thank you very much for the help!

[Sapphic Software]

Is this fair? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97913156&userid=1023823&signature=j3s0gpCYr5HYqVQGKZ1zfw

[Ashara]

How does this look? I'm not sure how much the crescent moon or red glove items are worth.

[airen]

is this fair?

I have no clue about item rarities so I’d love some help!

[abbie.]

could i get a second opinion on these trades?
1
2
would i be better off with my side?
thank you in advance!!

[Bridgy1234]

is this fair?

I have no clue about item rarities so I’d love some help!

Most items are worth an uncommon from their year. At a quick glance I think this trade may be unfair to you, I would wait for another opinion from someone who has the time to sit down and calculate the total value of each side.