The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ChellyBells93]

I already cancelled but I was wondering if this was fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97750877&userid=792268&signature=LPuPntlYfOJQPyxfxBz3bA

This was incredibly unfair to you. They don’t have any rares and the items they put in are typically worth 1 common-uncommon of the year it was released. You’re store pet alone is worth more than they offered

[Ghōst]

I already cancelled but I was wondering if this was fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97750877&userid=792268&signature=LPuPntlYfOJQPyxfxBz3bA

This was incredibly unfair to you. They don’t have any rares and the items they put in are typically worth 1 common-uncommon of the year it was released. You’re store pet alone is worth more than they offered

I was mostly asking because they added c$, but thank you :]

[Klex0s]

sorry to reply again so soon! but they resent the trade as this trades/viewtrade.php?id=97745738&userid=1017440&signature=oOeEfyirluPwSLxwawL43g and i was wondering if i should accept it this time? thank you in advance

[xephtyr]

Hi! Would this trade be considered fair for my ur smore??? If not, what would make it fair? Thank you in advance!

[nedbit]

Hey hey! Is this fair?

[sarr~]

how much is their side worth? sorry, lots of pets here^^ thank u in advance! trades/viewtrade.php?id=97717910&userid=325630&signature=8twezV1X4ZDLF3E1fHT_vQ

[Rowanberry]

is this fair/close enough to fair? AKA, is it worth accepting? heavily considering

[Sali]

Please help, thank you c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97572856&userid=273533&signature=CYEwgx0yhPPFUgsLXdap2g

[Karma.]

Hi! Would this trade be considered fair for my ur smore??? If not, what would make it fair? Thank you in advance!

smores seem to be going for 1.75 nons/3500 cs$ (source)

so their side:
warrior cats have been going for about 200c$ each. that's 400c$ in this trade (as the snow and halloween ones aren't really classed as the same)

i can't find much info on the malk dogs but i would assume they'd go for a minimum of 100c$ each due to rarity + demand and for example in this trade it would be worth about that much so that's 200c$

rainbow stripe = 150 c$ (source)

everything else i think will just be valued at the price of a vr/rare of the year so as a very rough estimate:
rat = 35 cs$
snow cat = 70 cs$
bw = 70 cs$
halloween cat = 25 cs$
blue dog = 70cs$
star dog = 70cs$
2021 dog = 7cs$ (best case scenario)
total: 347
* i don't have a source for this but i did use the "what is this cs pet worth" to work out an estimate


final total: 2097
so in my opinion they are underpaying you by about 1000-1500 cs$!

MINOR CORRECTION:
I have just found a trade that suggests that the blue stripe dogs and star dogs could potentially go up to about 100cs$ (source) so this could total up slightly higher if you take this into account


please note - this is all from my own research and from other trades i have found that are similar! this is subject to change!

[sapphirelion]

Please help, thank you c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97572856&userid=273533&signature=CYEwgx0yhPPFUgsLXdap2g

The only information I found is from 2018 (so it may be out of date), it says that your item is only worth a late 2012 uncommon. But like I said it could be out of date so I would get a second opinion/proof of it’s worth!

I got my information from the what is this item worth thread: Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3719854&p=116870300&hilit=Skeleton#p116870300

I have another paperclip question!

Is the one side with 3 pets worth more?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97750920&userid=964390&signature=wjK3zzOCJJjfGIDngw7Rug

Your pet is originally from March 2009 and just going by rarity/years it is a fair swap (so the other side is not worth more pet/rarity wise, it is worth the same). However I believe with the demand on your pet it might be unfair? I’m not 100% certain it has demand so I’d get another opinion, but I know the pps of this does have some demand