The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[PillowFriend]

What about this one?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97707780&userid=953391&signature=yyPPuVNpmu40MQIB3i1wsg

[ReignofRain]

Hi hi, wondering if this is considered a fair trade? I'm not very familiar with trading pre 2012 pets so I'm really unsure of worth here ;-;
Thank you ❤️

[lextopia]

opinions on these bids? one two three four
any help is appreciated, thanks in advance<3

[SaltyTrigger]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97706098&userid=11141&signature=p5rbyTVKBcxQ4WeIPLTH8Q

Is this fair for the UR Butterbun?

bumping because I’m their trading partner and I’d like to know as well c:

Unfair to the UR Butterbun.

UR Butterbun = 1 n

Red X PPS (.25n or 3-4 ma) + Valentines Day Malk Cat ( .5 ma or 4 '09 Rares) + 14 '09 Rares worth of non-list rares = about 5 ma or about .5 n. (Source)

They need to add .5 n of pets.

[OakForestFarm006]

What about this one?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97707780&userid=953391&signature=yyPPuVNpmu40MQIB3i1wsg

unfair to you. '09s can go anywhere from 30-50C$ (not exact depending on demand and what not) obviously butterfly wolves demands aren't the best but they aren't covering the cost of the 2 VRs.. the other rares don't add up either

[Melybelly]

They are asking me to add to this trade.

How much should I add?
I don't want to offer unfairly, however I also don't want to overpay for a re-release.

[iluka]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97708346&userid=1027455&signature=kLkK2lAtirelgIH04k68jA

[~WildFlower~]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97706098&userid=11141&signature=p5rbyTVKBcxQ4WeIPLTH8Q

Is this fair for the UR Butterbun?

bumping because I’m their trading partner and I’d like to know as well c:

Unfair to the UR Butterbun.

UR Butterbun = 1 n

Red X PPS (.25n or 3-4 ma) + Valentines Day Malk Cat ( .5 ma or 4 '09 Rares) + 14 '09 Rares worth of non-list rares = about 5 ma or about .5 n. (Source)

They need to add .5 n of pets.

thank you for your help! is it possible to get a second opinion?

[Nicnova]

Hi! Is this a fair trade?

The RBM foal is still growing, so it's uncertain what it'll be at this point in time.

EDIT; it was cancelled but i'd still like to know if it was fair! Thanks

[LiLi041]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97690390&userid=925966&signature=wy336B2IGmWdzJnfLkSikQ