The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[DitsyDruid]

How does this look?

Along with this and this?

[Ascension]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97644220&userid=877749&signature=uES3LpxSOGn24zxHZ56HFQ
one of them is an aug 2010 rerelease and the other is a 2008 special release rerelease
my first thought was that this isnt fair to me but im not completely sure so can someone help me out please :3

[lextopia]

hi there,
opinions on these bids for my cheetah pps?
one
two
three
four
any help is appreciated, thanks in advance<3

[Rancid Roadkill]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97666048&userid=72123&signature=BK-46-D1FMGe9XWEL55YjA

[Lex.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97644220&userid=877749&signature=uES3LpxSOGn24zxHZ56HFQ
one of them is an aug 2010 rerelease and the other is a 2008 special release rerelease
my first thought was that this isnt fair to me but im not completely sure so can someone help me out please :3

Unfair to the cake dog. The other side is hardly worth 1 MA, while the cake dog gets at least 2 MAs.
The BW store pet might get 1 MA, but the other pets don't make enough for 2.

[PlagueNBlight]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97674370&userid=994990&signature=0F2zty4hrhfq32uwULXwyA

I still need help with this trade, thank you in advance! ^^

[SaltyTrigger]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97644220&userid=877749&signature=uES3LpxSOGn24zxHZ56HFQ
one of them is an aug 2010 rerelease and the other is a 2008 special release rerelease
my first thought was that this isnt fair to me but im not completely sure so can someone help me out please :3

Unfair to the cake dog. The other side is hardly worth 1 MA, while the cake dog gets at least 2 MAs.
The BW store pet might get 1 MA, but the other pets don't make enough for 2.

The 2012 store pet is worth 1 ma and the other pets add up to .5 ma (1 ma = 6- 9 09 rares) so yes, unfair. The Flying Music Store dog goes for 1 09 rare. They need to at 2-3 09 rares

[DitsyDruid]

How does this look?

Along with this and this?

[moonbeam.]

hi there,
opinions on these bids for my cheetah pps?
one
two
three
four
any help is appreciated, thanks in advance<3

I am unsure with the others at the moment, but bid 1 is a MASSIVE overpay.

An MA is like 300 or so C$

700 C$ Could go up to a main list or so

Get a 2nd opinion tho!

[lextopia]

hi there,
opinions on these bids for my cheetah pps?
one
two
three
four
any help is appreciated, thanks in advance<3

I am unsure with the others at the moment, but bid 1 is a MASSIVE overpay.

An MA is like 300 or so C$

700 C$ Could go up to a main list or so

Get a 2nd opinion tho!

Thank you! That is what I'm thinking as well, but I also have experience trading pets for c$ and find
it quite hard to trade up with, so I'm just not sure. I'd love some second opinions!<3