The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Rbpuppy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97436169&userid=927092&signature=RWW5FZCTH5TnOaJovrYysA

This is actually slightly unfair to them. Their pets if a 2008 rerelease and your side is worth just under that. You’d have to add at least 1 more 2010 rare to make this fair since you’re short 1 09 Rare.

[AlatusNemeseos]

is this trade fair? i have a feeling it isn’t but i want to make sure just in case !

[Nicnova]

I’ve never been good with item rarities, and I only just recently came back, but this is overpay isn’t it? I just wanted to double check.

[Backstabbed]

What's the demand for both sides, id like to know if this a fair swap

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97514906&userid=1018830&signature=jwZ4YLY_sgFNkqDdL_dBHw

[kxynine]

What's the demand for both sides, id like to know if this a fair swap

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97514906&userid=1018830&signature=jwZ4YLY_sgFNkqDdL_dBHw

The Zonkey has been going for 1.5-2 nons (x) while the dogtag is at 1.5-2 nons aswell (x) and according to this the Zonkey seems to have a bit more demand than the dogtag. Tho I cannot say for sure as I've never owned either of them

[airen]

is this fair?

I’m trying to complete my butterfly wolf collection so this is tempting, I just wanted to check as I’m not sure of the lion’s value either!

thank you ^^

[virtualghost]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97514329&userid=877058&signature=R2J2-VFR2EiwZRXs5uYHJw

Been asking about this one I think it got lost in the last thread so I’m not sure if I ever got an answer. But is this fair? And if not what would make it fair?

[choerry]

how does this look?

[JayJay]

Need to know item value to make a fair trade please!
I know what some of them are worth. Like the sun dog is worth 1MA and the '09 Christmas decorations are 1 '09 rare each, I believe. But I don't know the value of anything else.

What is the Rabbit Nose item worth? and is this a fair trade for it? I believe that my side is worth about 5.5-6.5MA +.
True date Black and White Collie - 1.5MA
Evil PPS - 2-3MA
2nd Gen Valentines - .5MA (Oct list)
Blue/Green Grass Dog - .5MA (Oct list)
5 VR '09 dogs - 10 '09 Rares (which is a little over 1MA)

Last but not least, store scarves of this year. What are they worth? Is this a good trade for them?

Thank you so much for any help!

[Bria]

HI, please help look this trade over and see if it seems fair: I don't know pet CS$ values so could use the help, TY!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97521030&userid=60974&signature=vlQAKlF8_tYsZO7dZls9Qg