The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kxynine]

I'd love some thoughts on this bid for my TD Angel Advent ^^ Thank you in advance !
Trade

Unless those pets have specific demand, it's not fair to the angel advent.
TD Angel advent goes for 0.5 nons (5-7 MAs) and as far as I can see, they are nowhere on this guide, and according to this the fairy goat set can at best get one MA, but get a second opinion.

Edit; After looking here each fairy goat seems to be valued at 1 MA, which still only adds up to the low end of 0.5 nons (5-7 MAs)

[Leylard]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97503817&userid=991544&signature=VB6V-iK_lWFey9_eOrbxtg
thank you so much!

[Tawny-]

Any idea on the balance of this trade for the nick fox? I'm interested in the bulk since it helps fill my wishlist, just not sure if there's particular demand for this fella!

Still hoping for advice ♡

Advice would be appreciated

[- Alice -]

Any idea on the balance of this trade for the nick fox? I'm interested in the bulk since it helps fill my wishlist, just not sure if there's particular demand for this fella!

Still hoping for advice ♡

Advice would be appreciated

so this was a pain in the butt to work out but ROUGHLY their side works out at 2.5 09' uncommons. I used the 2;1 rule when it came to going up years and also for the commons to uncommons value! e.g. 2 commons from 2018 = 1 2018 uncommon and so on. I was fairly generous with my calculations as well! I am not sure how you value rares some do 4 uncommons of the same year = 1 rare but personally im not sure! :3 either way its up to you but I wanted to give you my maths pff

[Miladux]

Been asking for a while but could I get any help? I normally pretty good with small list trades but not so certain with this:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97514163&userid=402566&signature=qXlLA1T24ah8qKquOQnnAQ

[Pumpkin~Spice]

Is this fair? The Cream Santa advert for a tier 7 advert list? If not, what needs to be added to my side? Any help is appreciated.
Click

[Tawny-]

Any idea on the balance of this trade for the nick fox? I'm interested in the bulk since it helps fill my wishlist, just not sure if there's particular demand for this fella!

Still hoping for advice ♡

Advice would be appreciated

so this was a pain in the butt to work out but ROUGHLY their side works out at 2.5 09' uncommons. I used the 2;1 rule when it came to going up years and also for the commons to uncommons value! e.g. 2 commons from 2018 = 1 2018 uncommon and so on. I was fairly generous with my calculations as well! I am not sure how you value rares some do 4 uncommons of the same year = 1 rare but personally im not sure! :3 either way its up to you but I wanted to give you my maths pff

Thank you so much!

[Leylard]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97503817&userid=991544&signature=VB6V-iK_lWFey9_eOrbxtg
thank you so much!

[Pumpkin~Spice]

Is this fair? The Cream Santa advert for a tier 7 advert list? If not, what needs to be added to my side? Any help is appreciated.
Click

[cherri ♥︎]

hi all, just looking for opinions on this trade as i suck at value <3
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97516858&userid=906075&signature=2yJRAhyWokjg2nyRqs4f9w