The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Quackers <3]

How does this trade look?

[cloven]

I’m bad at item values- does this look okay?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97427226&userid=919435&signature=Mjt7cR38MwATQJKxcTX0_w

[kaiserbakura]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97425285&userid=901965&signature=zQB222dZMDj10zbalWjZMw

Also what kind of demand does the pineapple have Vs the Kirin?

Edit got this trade as well

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97427156&userid=901965&signature=efVSdSbIUbrcfGGS5tRiIg

Both are tempting but honestly I don't know if either are fairly.

[Sharkyy]

Is this a fair trade? I’m still new to worths hhh sorry if it’s a dumb question lol
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97427273&userid=891706&signature=Q0uHu-fgm0VBjn7ZRGFE7g

[☼ morgana]

Is it worth waiting to see what my dec 18 dog grows into or should I just do this trade rn? If I keep it and it ends up growing into the white july, is not taking the non much of a loss? Or vice versa - if I do trade it and it grows into july pps?
Basically I'm just wondering what is less of a (possible) loss considering the gaps between the july pps - nondogs - white july

i believe that both pets are worth about the same, if it grows into the GWJ, then it's a fair and probably worthwhile trade. If it becomes the july pps, then I think you'd be at a bit of a loss? but i can't say by how much. I'd say wait and see what it becomes, just to be on the safe side. maybe also let your trading partner know ?? up to you though

How does this trade look?

I think this is a bit unfair to you. For reference, a 2014 VR store pet I believe is worth around 1 MA, and this pet is 2013 store, so it's probably worth a bit more then that. Anyone is allowed to correct me if I am wrong, but I do feel as though this is not at all fair to you.

Is this a fair trade? I’m still new to worths hhh sorry if it’s a dumb question lol
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97427273&userid=891706&signature=Q0uHu-fgm0VBjn7ZRGFE7g

Yes, this is a good fair trade! Neither pets are ex lists, and are of the same month, year and rarity so yes, I think it's fair, however, I do think design wise, your pet may have a little more demand then the pet you're being offered.

--

If anyone else thinks my advice is incorrect please do tell me! I'm still learnin'

[Moonligh50]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97418928&userid=989119&signature=DB2jd1Bfzq_54unUmt67bg

Help please! I have so many more trds I need help on.

[magioffire]

hello!

are either of these trades fair and worthwhile/which one would you think is more worthwhile?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97425119&userid=1022032&signature=H_isZLerti3UmPIWWNVFng
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97424346&userid=1022032&signature=lEoBrL97o5q1-3cMENyVSw

thanks!

[jerky]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97418928&userid=989119&signature=DB2jd1Bfzq_54unUmt67bg

Help please! I have so many more trds I need help on.

i would definitely wait to trade your pumpkin and wait to see what it goes for in the next few days

[Thanaturgist]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97423515&userid=497788&signature=Cy9FrnwCPKXoXSGFHi8IlA

Is this fair to them? I don't mind if it's overpay on my end since that's one of the owls I'm missing

[TheRathianRider]

Currently trying to trade off/swap my Dec 18 Pets since I didn't get anything I really wanted. I got two offers that I'm tempted by but unsure of. I know that rarity/date wise they're definitely more than fair swaps, but considering I'd probably trade the pet I receive off, I'm wondering which one would be better?
1
2