The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Shawnyy]

Im not an item expert, reason why im here, but something tells me this aint a fair one

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96980806&userid=883422&signature=qeRzJ_qxDAc6V5lD9dqZAg

[Fishkin]

Trade help? I don't know if it's fair.

[Caslixe]

This? Tysm!

looking for a second opinion to be safe :)

[dillydallydarlene]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96983049&userid=47800&signature=W2-7pGOfmv0LF1Uu7Z1bTA

How fair is this?

[sapphirelion]

I just wanted to double check that the pps pup does not have any special demand? Or does it?
trade

(If it does have demand, can I please have some proofs to show my trade partner when I add things?)

[samiam52900]

Was this fair? I have been told multiple time that the 2:1 ratio for year and omgsc-uc and then a uncommon = a rare 2 years younger? thoughts?

[Fishkin]

Was this fair? I have been told multiple time that the 2:1 ratio for year and omgsc-uc and then a uncommon = a rare 2 years younger? thoughts?

No definitely not, you'd need at least an uncommon added onto that common. If not a bit more. very unfair to them. As rares tend to be valued more over commons. By the rule- yes you're correct. By usual trade values. No. Plus space pets (rares) tend to be overpaid for.
Edit: Realized I needed to explain more whoopsies

[mitts]

Was this fair? I have been told multiple time that the 2:1 ratio for year and omgsc-uc and then a uncommon = a rare 2 years younger? thoughts?

teeechnically fair by the 2:1 rule, but people generally favour rares over commons. also, space event pets are easier to get overpay for.

[Demonking Urizen]

Was this fair? I have been told multiple time that the 2:1 ratio for year and omgsc-uc and then a uncommon = a rare 2 years younger? thoughts?

No definitely not, you'd need at least an uncommon added onto that common. If not a bit more. very unfair to them.

if you go by the more common 2:1 rule lets take a look at this trade;
2016 rare (2 2016 uncommons) = a 2015 uncommon = a 2014 common
so this trade is unfair, but to the common side.
they would have to add another 2014 common to make it fair.

however, event pets tend to have a little higher value, especially from the 2013 slumber party / the 2016 space event

[sapphirelion]

I just wanted to double check that the pps pup does not have any special demand? Or does it?
trade

(If it does have demand, can I please have some proofs to show my trade partner when I add things?)