The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Deoledath]

I have two trades I'd like opinions on if someone is willing.

-Snip because not sure-

Trade Two involves store pets so I am big lost haha.

Thank you in advance

Your 2014 store pets are worth around 2 '09 rares + 1 '10 rare per pet and they are offering 1 early-'09 rerelease VR and 1 mid-'09 rerelease VR -- I'd say it's about fair, if not a tad unfair to you, but I recommend getting a 2nd opinion since I'm still new to rarity math and I'm unsure of the value difference between a R and a VR

[little34511]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96980680&userid=655071&signature=5I-nT2_DQDHv9HE44Q3Rcw
unsure of list value help

[Gelée Nova]

I have two trades I'd like opinions on if someone is willing.

-Snip because not sure-

Trade Two involves store pets so I am big lost haha.

Thank you in advance

Your 2014 store pets are worth around 2 '09 rares + 1 '10 rare per pet and they are offering 1 early-'09 rerelease VR and 1 mid-'09 rerelease VR -- I'd say it's about fair, if not a tad unfair to you, but I recommend getting a 2nd opinion since I'm still new to rarity math and I'm unsure of the value difference between a R and a VR

Hi! I actually would have to disagree - 2014 store pets currently are going around .5 of an MA (so about 3-4 2009 rares each, give or take), not to mention the Sakura Store Dog has good demand and could potentially fetch up to 1 MA. This would be unfair to the store pets!

(Also for regular rare / very rare differences most people use the 2 to 1 rule, which just means that one very rare = two rares from the same year!)

[Jelloskello]

Hello! So my trading partner and I aren't sure about the values on the store pets, so any advice on what to remove/add to make this fair would be very appreciated.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96978104&userid=993463&signature=DfS53dgJqsyO_X5jHIQ1JQ

Thank you!

[VARANG]

Hello! So my trading partner and I aren't sure about the values on the store pets, so any advice on what to remove/add to make this fair would be very appreciated.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96978104&userid=993463&signature=DfS53dgJqsyO_X5jHIQ1JQ

Thank you!

this is definetly an overpay.

[Assumed Gender]

Hello! So my trading partner and I aren't sure about the values on the store pets, so any advice on what to remove/add to make this fair would be very appreciated.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96978104&userid=993463&signature=DfS53dgJqsyO_X5jHIQ1JQ

Thank you!

this is definetly an overpay.

i 2nd that, the side with all the old rares is overpaying

[Jelloskello]

Hello! So my trading partner and I aren't sure about the values on the store pets, so any advice on what to remove/add to make this fair would be very appreciated.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96978104&userid=993463&signature=DfS53dgJqsyO_X5jHIQ1JQ

Thank you!

this is definetly an overpay.

Yes, I suspected so, but do you have advice on what to remove from the top? I'm sorry for the trouble, but we weren't really sure what to do to make it equal since neither of us generally trade. That really seemed like a lot lol!
Thank you for replying so fast!

[VARANG]

was this fair for a 2009 VR wolf? tysm in advance

[Alina]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96965171&userid=261955&signature=v9nbzq6mgb9JY3Te5i99Jw

there are 211 items on their side

[Caslixe]

This? Tysm!