The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Delest Wolf]

Thoughts on these trades?

Trade 1
Trade 2

[VARANG]

hey was this a fair trade? they said they were over, how much were they over if so, they were very kind

thankyouforlooking

[LavenderHaze]

hey was this a fair trade? they said they were over, how much were they over if so, they were very kind

thankyouforlooking

Yes, they were over by about 1 MA. Their side is 2 MA and yours is 1.

[Gummy.Worm]

is this fair? X

[canid]

hey was this a fair trade? they said they were over, how much were they over if so, they were very kind

thankyouforlooking


their pet is a grinner, which is a mid september. your side is the cream santa hat, which is a mid advent :]
using this thread as a guide, the green grinner is worth two mid advents, so twice the value of your pet! they definitely overpaid ^__^

[VARANG]

hey was this a fair trade? they said they were over, how much were they over if so, they were very kind

thankyouforlooking

Yes, they were over by about 1 MA. Their side is 2 MA and yours is 1.

hey was this a fair trade? they said they were over, how much were they over if so, they were very kind

thankyouforlooking


their pet is a grinner, which is a mid september. your side is the cream santa hat, which is a mid advent :]
using this thread as a guide, the green grinner is worth two mid advents, so twice the value of your pet! they definitely overpaid ^__^

thank you both so very much ''}

[WindRider]

Hi, I need some help with a trade. I'm not sure what the VR Alicorn Store pets typically go for, and I don't know item rarites either. Would this be fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96912624&userid=49293&signature=UxjdGai3Ap4R5u4e_20rzw

[canid]

is this fair? X



your side is a mid september list, worth about 1.5 - 2 mid advents [ source ]. their side is an tier 2 advent pet on the old list, but isnt on the current list as far as i can tell. the thread i linked previously values it at 2 MA's, so it could be seen as fair, but take it with a grain of salt as there doesnt seem to be much information on its trade value. you might want a second opinion ^__^;

[Akila]

Can someone please help me with this list trade?

I checked the 'new' condensed rarity list and the explanation and examples of the tiers and trades.
If i got it right, the sorbet buns go up and down a lot and are worth around a mid advent because of it..?
The spider seems to be a high september and goes for more at times.. so I think I'm overpaying a bit, even considering that spiders have a lower demand..? o:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96911111&userid=251473&signature=FuMzVcsJ_TzBlUzGY3sQ2A

[KamikazeDaBigBadWolf]

I know warrior cats are worth a bit. But I think the PPS lion is as well? I am so bad at old pet trades lol. Thanks in advance if this is fair or not!!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96887954&userid=25933&signature=UZYjlnXdlAfWMzWJAcz2dg