The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[itspaypay]

Thank you! I have two trades I was wondering if they are fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96008562&userid=896870&signature=gMVLxsDf-WZeU4oR_VWQQw

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96008461&userid=896870&signature=8ynvVEliViXfs-zaeEcegg

first trade is unfair to them. although people do overpay for those foxes as they are high in demand and hard to find, they are overpaying immensely

Thank you

[itspaypay]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96008461&userid=896870&signature=8ynvVEliViXfs-zaeEcegg

Thank you for helping me, I just really suck at this stuff honestly. So thank you!

Is this fair for a malk 2009 owl?

[Geckos_N_Tea]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96008843&userid=818213&signature=5N2RwoDJcI5d1ztGnYswEg

is this fair ? thansk so much ! :]

your overpaying, technically their side is worth a 2018 rare although it trades for more since these pets are high demand

[piff]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96008942&userid=818213&signature=15HDpxcRpRmGSj3GTCbAjw

thanks again ! im bad at trading haha but would this be better ?

[Hyensa]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96008478&userid=470278&signature=LZz_UKLzTvPcEt7c3SrU-g

I am incredibly stumped on this negotiation.

[Gelée Nova]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96008478&userid=470278&signature=LZz_UKLzTvPcEt7c3SrU-g

I am incredibly stumped on this negotiation.

This is very unfair to the items! The item side is worth about 1-1.25 nons + 5 MAs, the store pet side only adds up to around 4 MAs. Using this thread - The Shampoo, Flower tail bracelet, and Angel wings are worth .25 of a non each. The Wizard token is worth around .25-.5 nons, and the other items are worth a MA each.
They would have to add around 1-1.25 nons + an MA in order to make this fair!

[Hyensa]

@Shvlby
Thank you so much for the answer.

[moonbeam.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96006623&userid=758444&signature=zRnDKAumWJZDQbTUTUkB5w

Should I?

[Feather <3]

Hi! Could I get some help with the value of store pets vs. '08/'09 rares?

Thanks so much!

[Nira.]

Hi! Could I get some help with the value of store pets vs. '08/'09 rares?

Thanks so much!

Hi, here´s a bit from the conversion list I use when trading store pets:
2015 = 2 2009 rares
2014 = 2 09 rares + 2010 rare
2013 = ~3-6 09 rares / Oct/Low advent
Kitsune is popular and has high demand - worth 1-1.5 MA (= 6-9 2009 rares)

Malk pets have a bit of demand as far as I know, I can´t say precisely what these two go for atm though

Anyway;
Their side: 14-17 2009 Rares
Your side: +- 9 2009 Rares (08 R = 2 09 Rs ; Malk dog, + I added additional 1 09 R to the malk wolf to cover potential demand)

I hope this helps, but feel free to get second opinion though c: