The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[updog]

removed

[Strawberry_dreams]

Item Trade
Please let me know if either side needs to add more! Thanks so much!

Edit
also, a bulk item trade. I mostly want to know the values of the earlier items (2008 merry Christmas sign, I love you signs)
Trade

I hate to keep adding to the list but, one more, again, a bit of bulk, please just focus on the older items+pets
Ding!

the second one isnt fair to you. most of those items are recent and not worth that much

and the third one is the wrong link

[Ice_Dragon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95989499&userid=783020&signature=5qEnRhwIGNiO-yYMxMUPCA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95999436&userid=783020&signature=fYuSge_GPhLJB-4Dnc2GTA

Is this fair?

Still need help on these

[Strawberry_dreams]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95989499&userid=783020&signature=5qEnRhwIGNiO-yYMxMUPCA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95999436&userid=783020&signature=fYuSge_GPhLJB-4Dnc2GTA

Is this fair?

Still need help on these

the top one is unfair to them, the C$ is more than enough to cover your side. id value your pets at about 8 C$ each or so.
The second one the rat is enough as the sloths are only a '10 rare and that rat is a VR

[tremolite]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95999516&userid=955327&signature=x_COSgMO6F801mi3qRd9mg

is this fair? brain's too frazzled rn to try and figure it out myself

[Strawberry_dreams]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95999516&userid=955327&signature=x_COSgMO6F801mi3qRd9mg

is this fair? brain's too frazzled rn to try and figure it out myself

its unfair to them. all of yours are too recent to add up to their side. The 2016 uncommons are a fair swap. its hard to add though because there isnt pairs. but your side is still too recent

[Cartier]

Item Trade
Please let me know if either side needs to add more! Thanks so much!

Edit
I hate to keep adding to the list but, one more, again, a bit of bulk, please just focus on the older items+pets
Ding!

the second one isnt fair to you. most of those items are recent and not worth that much

and the third one is the wrong link

Link is fixed!

[Rookspirit]

help? trades/viewtrade.php?id=96000466&userid=762403&signature=jnVciuFzH8ZLYD49vO87vw

[Strawberry_dreams]

help? trades/viewtrade.php?id=96000466&userid=762403&signature=jnVciuFzH8ZLYD49vO87vw

Unfair to them the 2016 rare does not equal the 2014 rare on their side. But the others are swaps

[Aktori]

Thoughts?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96000424&userid=737315&signature=NOIwNGkXb0citxPQClOtXA