The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Babypoke]

the trade thankyouis this fair?

[Geckos_N_Tea]

(this screenshot is so big, im sorry)

godking, in the past you've said that cheshire most commonly gets 2-3 ma and now you seem to be changing what you've said. its difficult to say what cheshire is really worth as looking at the successful trades thread, it has been valued at 2 ma and even up to .25n numerous times. its really up to how the person with Cheshire values it, as in the end is it a unique looking store pet. a 2020 rerelease looks nowhere near appealing as the Cheshire (in my opinion)

So then, what is the Cheshire worth? If the value keeps changing it becomes hard to even trust this thread for advice now.

i mean godking isn’t wrong… they said that both the shima and cheshire go for 2 ma. which is correct. but honestly why would you bring this screenshot up? just to prove someone wrong? they haven’t said anything wrong or false, both pets do get 2ma , they just didn’t specify how much is the higher end of its worth. and value does keep changing, and honestly this thread isn’t going to be a good advice place, it’s better to get to know your pet values and have a rough estimate then come on the thread.

[.kyungsoo]

(this screenshot is so big, im sorry)

godking, in the past you've said that cheshire most commonly gets 2-3 ma and now you seem to be changing what you've said. its difficult to say what cheshire is really worth as looking at the successful trades thread, it has been valued at 2 ma and even up to .25n numerous times. its really up to how the person with Cheshire values it, as in the end is it a unique looking store pet. a 2020 rerelease looks nowhere near appealing as the Cheshire (in my opinion)

So then, what is the Cheshire worth? If the value keeps changing it becomes hard to even trust this thread for advice now.

i mean godking isn’t wrong… they said that both the shima and cheshire go for 2 ma. which is correct. but honestly why would you bring this screenshot up? just to prove someone wrong? they haven’t said anything wrong or false, both pets do get 2ma , they just didn’t specify how much is the higher end of its worth. and value does keep changing, and honestly this thread isn’t going to be a good advice place, it’s better to get to know your pet values and have a rough estimate then come on the thread.

I personally did not bring up this screenshot so I don’t understand why I am being targeted for it. If it has been said in the past that it has a different value than mentioned now, it does make me wonder - I think that’s a valid point. Nothing against Godking, they’ve given me great advice in the past but it shouldn’t be a crime to question advice either.

[Geckos_N_Tea]

-snip-
I personally did not bring up this screenshot so I don’t understand why I am being targeted for it. If it has been said in the past that it has a different value than mentioned now, it does make me wonder - I think that’s a valid point. Nothing against Godking, they’ve given me great advice in the past but it shouldn’t be a crime to question advice either.

ah i’m sorry if it made you feel like i wasn’t targeting you! i wasn’t questioning you at all, and i do feel that it’s great to question advice as well. i was just bringing up that they hadn’t said false advice, i didn’t mean to direct it towards you ;-; (i’m sorry if i wording this in a hateful or rude way to anyone, i mean no harm)

[Cartier]

Item Trade
Please let me know if either side needs to add more! Thanks so much!

[Kruziik]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95999666&userid=789212&signature=w8xWaT2GRPqvrLN6JdntHQ
Is this fair? I feel like it is but also im not exactly sure, thank you in advance!

[Cartier]

Item Trade
Please let me know if either side needs to add more! Thanks so much!

Edit
also, a bulk item trade. I mostly want to know the values of the earlier items (2008 merry Christmas sign, I love you signs)
Trade

[ggez]

(this screenshot is so big, im sorry)

godking, in the past you've said that cheshire most commonly gets 2-3 ma and now you seem to be changing what you've said. its difficult to say what cheshire is really worth as looking at the successful trades thread, it has been valued at 2 ma and even up to .25n numerous times. its really up to how the person with Cheshire values it, as in the end is it a unique looking store pet. a 2020 rerelease looks nowhere near appealing as the Cheshire (in my opinion)

So then, what is the Cheshire worth? If the value keeps changing it becomes hard to even trust this thread for advice now. :/

i mean godking isn’t wrong… they said that both the shima and cheshire go for 2 ma. which is correct. but honestly why would you bring this screenshot up? just to prove someone wrong? they haven’t said anything wrong or false, both pets do get 2ma , they just didn’t specify how much is the higher end of its worth. and value does keep changing, and honestly this thread isn’t going to be a good advice place, it’s better to get to know your pet values and have a rough estimate then come on the thread.

it wasn't even false information at the time tho. they were wrong to call that false information, and they have been wrong in multiple other msgs on this thread as well. no this thread doesn't have the most accurate of values, but people like godking seem to keep it that way

tldr.
alt said that it can get 3ma and he disagreed with her. she wasn't wrong or giving false information; godking gave false information when he called her wrong

[LoveIsLove]

(this screenshot is so big, im sorry)

godking, in the past you've said that cheshire most commonly gets 2-3 ma and now you seem to be changing what you've said. its difficult to say what cheshire is really worth as looking at the successful trades thread, it has been valued at 2 ma and even up to .25n numerous times. its really up to how the person with Cheshire values it, as in the end is it a unique looking store pet. a 2020 rerelease looks nowhere near appealing as the Cheshire (in my opinion)

So then, what is the Cheshire worth? If the value keeps changing it becomes hard to even trust this thread for advice now.

i mean godking isn’t wrong… they said that both the shima and cheshire go for 2 ma. which is correct. but honestly why would you bring this screenshot up? just to prove someone wrong? they haven’t said anything wrong or false, both pets do get 2ma , they just didn’t specify how much is the higher end of its worth. and value does keep changing, and honestly this thread isn’t going to be a good advice place, it’s better to get to know your pet values and have a rough estimate then come on the thread.

If you go back a few pages you can see that alt brought the screenshot up due to being corrected by godking’s heretic on the range value that they shared. Not trying to say anyone is right or wrong but it is best not to judge anything out of context.

[Ice_Dragon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95989499&userid=783020&signature=5qEnRhwIGNiO-yYMxMUPCA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95999436&userid=783020&signature=fYuSge_GPhLJB-4Dnc2GTA

Is this fair?

Still need help on these