The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Demonking Urizen]

is this fair?https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95608953&userid=1018858&signature=iipLTwrc7z8J16pgPw8HNg

I have seen the Nightmare twins going for various and different offers, from a 2013 rare up to 1-2 '09 rares. the pet they're offering on is worth a late '10 rare, so it's your personal preference

[Gelée Nova]

Hello! Could I please get anyone's opinions on these two trades? Taking demand into consideration, would either of these be worth taking?

Thanks in advance for any advice! c:

[Demonking Urizen]

Hello! Could I please get anyone's opinions on these two trades? Taking demand into consideration, would either of these be worth taking?

Thanks in advance for any advice! c:

Trade 1: unfair to you. the bee trades for 2.5-3n
their side adds up to 1.75n (Grinners 1.5 ma each, red-fronted holly 1 ma, husky 1 ma, Joker bun 1n)

Trade 2. raritywise fair to the bee
their side adds up 2.5n (July pps 1n, galaxy cat 1.5n) + 1 ma (300 c$) + one '09 rare (51 c$)
however, the july pps doesn't have the best demand and is relatively hard to trade away.

I've definitely seen better trades for the bee, so I wouldn't even take the fair one.

[hexcore]

~ would a orange punk be a fair swap for a yellow android, taking demand into consideration?
(i understand that they're both worth 0.5 each but i'm not sure how different the demand is between the two.)
thank you in advance! ~

[CoffeeEX]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95608977&userid=881679&signature=NXrYkn-1D0fJhMgl8wVuAQ

could i please get some insight on this trade? tysm!

[pitachip]

Hi! This trade is tempting me as it contains a dreamie of mine (and I'd like to note I value re-releases the same as their true dates), but I'd like to check if it's fair? I have trouble telling with anymore than three pets on each side, so thank you in advance!

The trade in question; https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95604391&userid=890986&signature=stfibBh-5xhfBKAPd0mY9g

[Demonking Urizen]

~ would a orange punk be a fair swap for a yellow android, taking demand into consideration?
(i understand that they're both worth 0.5 each but i'm not sure how different the demand is between the two.)
thank you in advance! ~

from what I've seen there is no overall different demand of the same-valued punks and androids.
it's all a question of personal preference.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95608977&userid=881679&signature=NXrYkn-1D0fJhMgl8wVuAQ

could i please get some insight on this trade? tysm!

The Galaxy cat trades for 1.5n
their side adds up to 1n or 11 ma (every pet but the cake dog is 1 ma each, the cake dog is 2 ma)
therefore the trade is unfair to you by 0.5n

[xvi]

Hello! I was just wondering if this trade was fair.

Edit: This one too please.

Any help is appreciated so, so much!

[Geckos_N_Tea]

Hi! This trade is tempting me as it contains a dreamie of mine (and I'd like to note I value re-releases the same as their true dates), but I'd like to check if it's fair? I have trouble telling with anymore than three pets on each side, so thank you in advance!

The trade in question; https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95604391&userid=890986&signature=stfibBh-5xhfBKAPd0mY9g

unless i’m mistaken this is unfair to them. the 2011 and 2012 pets are worth more that your side. unless you side are store pets, i don’t think they are. this is unfair to them. i recommend another opinion tho! <3

[beantrio]

is this fair?https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95610575&userid=1018858&signature=fAQSy4n3M4PJsbQZMCk7qw