The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[itsliza]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95608180&userid=772106&signature=e-zR3TDkV0D5DTACb19TVQ

[draculauraaa]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95608180&userid=772106&signature=e-zR3TDkV0D5DTACb19TVQ

zodiacs are worth about 2-3 09 rares, so this is unfair to you :)

[lazy16]

Hi! I'm not great with items and their values - I know plushies are high demand -- help please?? ^.^

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95608261&userid=385897&signature=NDtFMQVph9-Ydk8zmykkSA

[beestie]

hey ya'll, sorry for the bulk trade. i'm semi-quitting, so fair trades aren't a *huge* deal to me atm, but just wanna make sure i'm getting at least a semi-reasonable bang for my buck here. again, sorry for the bulk trade - just hoping for some feedback :) ty!

x

demand doesn't matter to me because i'm quitting general pet collection, the pets added on their side are pets im actively searching for and will be keeping. so that being said, ignoring demand, does anyone have a second opinion on rarity fairness for the bulk?

there are 150 cats on the bulk side, 20-ish pets on the non-bulk side i believe

would like a second opinion pls & ty

also, this trade please. i'm not great with item trades.

[xvi]

Hello! I was just wondering if this trade was fair.

Any help is appreciated so, so much!

[grassman.]

this trade fair? not great with bulk trades ^^”

[draculauraaa]

this trade fair? not great with bulk trades ^^”

theyre definitely under by a lot. im pretty sure youre pet is worth a '10 rare and theyre side doesnt add up to that at all

[Ocelover567]

This is a pretty low value trade but I'm just curious if it's considered balanced or not
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95608054&userid=2093&signature=uTlmpLbdXjOKpwVWBLmN2Q

[Bridgy1234]

This is a pretty low value trade but I'm just curious if it's considered balanced or not
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95608054&userid=2093&signature=uTlmpLbdXjOKpwVWBLmN2Q

Very unbalanced. Those two rares are worth about 4-6c$ each, though I’ve seen them values a little higher. Everything they are offering is technically worth less than 1c$ though many value an uncommon at 1c$ for simplicity.

If those are pets you are really wanting, they would be worth only one of the rares, but o personally wouldn’t do it as you could easily swap for those pets or find them in the pound

[Demonking Urizen]

this trade fair? not great with bulk trades ^^”

considering your pet is worth a late '10 rare the quantity on their side definitely doesn't make up for that.

This is a pretty low value trade but I'm just curious if it's considered balanced or not
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95608054&userid=2093&signature=uTlmpLbdXjOKpwVWBLmN2Q

Very unbalanced. Those two rares are worth about 4-6c$ each, though I’ve seen them values a little higher. Everything they are offering is technically worth less than 1c$ though many value an uncommon at 1c$ for simplicity.

If those are pets you are really wanting, they would be worth only one of the rares, but o personally wouldn’t do it as you could easily swap for those pets or find them in the pound

please do not convert pets into c$ values to explain the fairness of a trade if c$ isn't involved.
it doesn't work like that.

however, the trade is unfair to the rares, if you value a rare as 2-3 uncommons of the same year.
a 2018 rare would be 12 uncommons from 2021.