The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Rancid Roadkill]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95540408&userid=72123&signature=3L4MSUt65hGQRvLcGUuLdg

Is this fair?

[Strange_Atoms]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95534644&userid=751421&signature=GQiecv-8FvzVMWWvuZ9ftA

[Pastel-Axle]

im asking about this trade pretty much everywhere, but im wondering how much my side equals to? its a pretty big trade and im unsure on some of the rarities myself, so I'd love some help with this. I'm also wondering what a raven is worth? I've heard its 4n to 4.5n? (:

trade!

not sure on your side i need to add from first glance tho it looks between 2-4 nons could be wrong as i do need to add but estimating what i see there its in that range i know its a large range.
but the raven is 4-5 nons from what ive seen of late.

it’s definitely more then 2n bud.. the pickle itself is 1n, zebra 0.75n (I think) and the dark heart rat is 0.25n. I just need help with the rest as people value store pets differently and im not too sure how to value them

I've been doing a lot of store trading recently, and this is what I've experienced! Get a second opinion as this is only based on trades which I've done, but it has come from a fair number of trades.

2016 and '17 stores all go for a '09 rare each (early for '16, mid for '17.) Some might say they go for more, but in my experience they all trade fairly easily at those values (including the unicorns though they are popular). You might be able to get a '09 rare more than that, but that's dependent on the trader.

2015 stores are 2 '09 rares each, though the deer can go for a little bit more due to their popularity at the moment. I wouldn't say they go for a MA as some people do, as in my recent experience I've been able to get them for that sort of price, maybe at a '09 rare or two more for the deer. Definitely below MA worth though.

2014 stores are easily the most confusing part of this trade as their value is less solid. Some I've been able to get for 3 '09 rares, others I've had to pay 5 '09 rares. I'd stop short of valuing them at a MA though, due to how '12 stores trade which are rarer. 2013 stores trade very similarly, I've gotten my last few for 3 and 5 '09 rares worth respectively. Some of the pets featured here are popular (eg; pitbull) so maybe they could command overpay?

2012 stores, such as the fairy goat, are a solid MA. The Cheshire trades differently, but all of the others are a MA each.

[Geckos_N_Tea]

this is quite tempting to take as i’ve struggled to trade off this guy, but i don’t know if it’s exactly fair because grinners have really bad demand. so is this fair? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95541808&userid=900146&signature=c8c1oyT8K9qfpblI5RoyKg

Edit: this too https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95542795&userid=900146&signature=iInocCAHekGb7xZ63WctdA

[.:Cleverfox:.]

is this fair? i never trade items

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95534458&userid=699523&signature=WXxfnZSKCnBnFOj3qLr9_Q

[sydneydf]

Any thoughts on this trade? or this trade? thanks in advance!!

[Mosstera]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95531447&userid=196271&signature=OxFch2ZOkfxgqDaXFRnzCg

Is this fair?

Can I get some help with this item trade offer
Help really appreciated

[beantrio]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95542719&userid=1018858&signature=KUR5qoXV10AoKS6gFquLVg
is this fair?

[Kakegurui]

This fair? I have no idea on worth of the horse..

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95542775&userid=922448&signature=A1iPswioa_u2AQQnlVSoJQ

[Razzle_Dazzle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95541653&userid=1015147&signature=LMLFO3rEjrmTvq1Y1jEvPw

The trades already been accepted, but I just want to see if it was fair to both sides! Thank you in advance!

Just gonna bump this sorry-