The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Rancid Roadkill]

Thank you for the answer!
How about these?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95531033&userid=72123&signature=FX5r_C5Qy8MWzoLfGCGeEA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95531045&userid=72123&signature=bbX1mUUduqYKs3ubliH8MQ

[Geckos_N_Tea]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95530712&userid=994729&signature=9lfSnx_Ih3PLg7sVjpBsTw

imo this is unfair to you. UR squid has a value 0.5-0.75 nons. grinners are worth 2 ma’s each but have really bad demand, but for this trade i will value them at 2ma’s. the 2014 store (not with demand) would be worth about a low advent. 6 ma’s and a low advent would be about 0.5 nons. so saying that the squid can go for 0.5- 0.75, and grinners having very low demand, i would say this is unfair to you. i’m not sure in the store pets value tho, so i would double check my advice by getting a second opinion. all my advice was calculated using this chart.

[ghostly,]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95531251&userid=338901&signature=09DirMdZmAE_vIQWOHih-g Please help

[sakamoto]

Need some opinions on this trade please!
Thank you!!

[blurry_cat1]

Need some opinions on this trade please!
Thank you!!

Their side is up to 2009 rare only

[Geckos_N_Tea]

Need some opinions on this trade please!
Thank you!!

imo unfair to you. they’ve offered 2 late 2010 rare which have the value of a 2010 vr. sure lions do have good demand but so do malks. so they’ve offered the value of a late 2010 vr for a early 2009 rare, unfair to you! i would get a second opinion tho!

[/nyx.]

Help please.

[natabee]

Is this fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95531271&userid=417961&signature=xDW7OPJFVY--yZKQhrmGLg

[musicgurl333]

Need some opinions on this trade please!
Thank you!!

imo unfair to you. they’ve offered 2 late 2010 rare which have the value of a 2010 vr. sure lions do have good demand but so do malks. so they’ve offered the value of a late 2010 vr for a early 2009 rare, unfair to you! i would get a second opinion tho!

Agreed on all points. I wouldn't accept.

[Pastel-Axle]

Would love some opinions on these trades, if some are unfair for the other side or if they look fair for both sides;

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=95518280&userid=707159&signature=XbkFlPyY_jRObISC-jq01Q

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=95511109&userid=707159&signature=Q434Rze-5pZdYcmpF_U3Ig

3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=95520184&userid=707159&signature=ttXjtjnQ8C6dgmx_mxgkJw

4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=95520670&userid=707159&signature=3WQx3LYgIL_squnz2XV2Ng

5. trades/viewtrade.php?id=95520580&userid=707159&signature=1XsGpH2yEw1Y0014SJgzUw

6. trades/viewtrade.php?id=95522484&userid=707159&signature=FNr9LQVwje3RDAM1QCn2Bg <- this one if it's one off or if raven's are really more consistent at the 4 nons? There's bit mixed info on this.

Bumping this up for my trade partner ^^