The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Pastel-Axle]

Would this trade be fair? I am assuming the Gryphons to be the ‘maximum’ of their common trading value.

[Rancid Roadkill]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95525125&userid=72123&signature=SGC0Wian0dLeKrYfxR-sgQ
But also, what is demand like for the bumblebee?

[Demonking Urizen]

Hello! Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=95527813&userid=206448&signature=jmYV_kEBYHShu8OOi7DWuw
I don't really care about the pets on their side personally, as I'm only collecting rates to get the VR Bee

Unfair to you.
The Malk Elemental cats are somewhere between 0.5-1 mid advent, or 3-9 '09 rares.
Their side only adds up to 1.5 '09 rares.

Would this trade be fair? I am assuming the Gryphons to be the ‘maximum’ of their common trading value.

Unfair to you.
The Gryphons are 1.5 mid advents each.
The only 2011 store pets fetching more are the Arabians and the Basilisks.
The Target dog is 2 mid advents+ (more like 2.5 mid advents), so your side adds up to 4-4.5 mid advents.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95525125&userid=72123&signature=SGC0Wian0dLeKrYfxR-sgQ
But also, what is demand like for the bumblebee?

The demand of the bee is fine, it is going for 2.5-3n, depending on the pets offered.
Your side is 2.75n (1.5 ma each for both huskies, 1n for the ice cat and 1.5n for the rr Joker)

[Demonking Urizen]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95528254&userid=879265&signature=kV0jQsBrfRHV62g5TWji1A

is this trade fair?

Unfair to you. they are only offering 2 mid + late '10 rares for 3 early '10 rares.

[Sam I Am]

I've been gone since 2018 and cant grasp rarity and demands well, is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95527966&userid=461909&signature=gBl0JmVBUcjjPvYtT21aGg

[Quail]

Was this fair?

I declined purely because way it was too many of my rares/very rares to go in one trade but am so out of touch with trading I have no clue if it was overpay or fair

Just curious if anyone has any input c:

[rainfall.]

hi! would you accept this? i have absolutely no clue about values or anything nowadays </3
thank you in advance <33

[meged321]

Hi, they have done their research just wanted a second opinion as I am always nervous with trades like these,

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95528466&userid=667686&signature=31GC8maZXy9kpJeStAIL2Q

Thank you for any help!!

[Hauntednightmares]

Is this fair for my patchwork? Should I accept considering their side offers no store pets?

[Polyphia]

Hi, they have done their research just wanted a second opinion as I am always nervous with trades like these,

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95528466&userid=667686&signature=31GC8maZXy9kpJeStAIL2Q

Thank you for any help!!

definitely not fair to you, they're underpaying by quite a bit