The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Nosebleeds]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95099216&userid=955940&signature=1Ca4btkiwqriJ95NxkrQTA
I'm wondering if this is fair. Demand also taken into consideration.

[Mewfles]

Click me!
Looking for an opinion or two on this trade? I know Hollydog last I knew had various worths

[Mewfles]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95053907&userid=938139&signature=GJwUmGaYcNV6hPws1FHITQ
How does this sound? Am I overpaying? Thanks

I would wait until rarities come out, or look on the event outcomes thread, however to me it looks like you are overpaying, however a second opinion would be good, in case the axolotls have an upped demand!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95099216&userid=955940&signature=1Ca4btkiwqriJ95NxkrQTA
I'm wondering if this is fair. Demand also taken into consideration.

For this I would say unfair to you demand wise, malk has decent demand, however if this is a warrior cat I see them go from between 100-150C$ per cat

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95135473&userid=1010496&signature=R0iSocgKtgMkraV0zGYQ9A

Can someone give me insight on this trade?

Looks unfair, I don't want to individually add every item, but they all seem to be from recent years, an item goes for about a common-vc depending on the item from its year however they also have some from 2014 and earlier on your side, I would have them add on their end the 2020 rare though is worth about 8-16 recent items and the 2017 uncommon would be worth 32 items from this year whilst the 2017 vcs would be worth about 8 each to figure out value I would use a 2 by 1 rule, a 2019 common = 2 2020 commons and a rare = 2 uncommon = 4 common!

how does this look, just like estimate wise?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=95134758&userid=539362&signature=Gzx4ipaRuzSWnneinEf4HA
I understand all the pets are still growing and the values aren't out yet, but I was curious if it looks fair

Looking at demand per pet would be best in a case like this, some outcomes are more wanted than others, but with a quick glance over I would say unfair to you, tokens typically sell for 2C$ per, and Crystals to be a bit higher (on average) so adding the cost of tokens would be a safe bet until the rarities come out, I also typically see people pay a rare/uncommon per pet out of uncertainty!

[_M e o w y_]

I don't really know much about the value of items, and whether or not this is a fair trade. Some of the items in this trade are from the 2011 medieval fair event.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95136442&userid=215460&signature=Cwfvid002_efozqZQPWymg

[Mewfles]

I don't really know much about the value of items, and whether or not this is a fair trade. Some of the items in this trade are from the 2011 medieval fair event.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95136442&userid=215460&signature=Cwfvid002_efozqZQPWymg

How I typically view items worth is a common-uncommon for earlier years, and for recent years a common-very common, overall a common for it's year should work. so if you have their side, it's worth 1 2012 uncommon and 1 2011 common, therefore one item from the medieval event would be fair. (using a 2 to 1 ratio for year and rarity)

[Disintegration]

just want one last opinion on this - thank you

[Gelée Nova]

I don't really know much about the value of items, and whether or not this is a fair trade. Some of the items in this trade are from the 2011 medieval fair event.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=95136442&userid=215460&signature=Cwfvid002_efozqZQPWymg

I would say this is unfair to the items. You have about 5 items from the 2011 medieval faire which I'm going to assume have no special demand and are worth about an uncommon from that year- Those items alone would be overpay for their pet, let alone the add!

[Geckos_N_Tea]

is this fair? i want to make sure both of us get a good deal.https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95103712&userid=900146&signature=tnqdDKT6DZVcdGNvCcv-QQ any help is appreciated, thank you! <3 c:

any help appreciated!

the trade got cancelled because one of the pets in their side got traded away, but i would like to know the fairness of this for the future, thank you!

[Constellation.]

How's this trade for my white malk dragob? (: Neither my partner nor I have really a good idea of what it normall trades for so advice would be great!

[Kitkat2716]

Hey everyone! Any help for this guy would be super appreciated!
I also need help on this trade. I do like the quantity. I’m not a fan of the rats but the tokens are a big plus. However I’m not sure where to put them as value in this kind of trade. Is there any suggestions?