The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Toxique]

Is this fair?

[Bluestar502]

looking for a second opinion on this item trade, I'm not good with trading items ^^
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95025456&userid=566705&signature=Yr1SRV_3cZ52T7pMJdOFIg

looking for some advice on this trade, it feels unfair to me but I'm not sure
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95052682&userid=566705&signature=QNYnRxVcQnwZuiwV1vEweA

feedback on either of these would be highly appreciated! ^^

Given that the enchanted cat is a little older than the Dino plush and they were both given out for free, I’d say this is either fair or very slight overpay.

As for the second trade, it really all depends if you value dates or rarities more, and which side you’d rather own. As far as rarities go, this would be unfair to you as the butterfly wolf is much more scarce than the two very commons. But if you follow the 2:1 date rule, some users would say this is overpay. I personally would not take this trade, seeing as the 2:1 date rule is really only feasible for measuring older pets, and going down two jumps in rarity severely undervalues the 2021 uncommon.

thank you ^^

[Neoncherry64]

Is this fair?

It is hard to say if this trade is fair, because the rarities of the pets have not been revealed yet. I personally would not take this trade, as almost all of your pets are token trade-in pets and are likely to turn uncommon and rare.

[Sweetfrog]

Opinions on this trade? I like the pets on their end but I haven't traded liontails in a bit and was wondering if this is a good offer for them. (:

Hi all! I’m on the other side of the trade and would love some insight as well!

[Toxique]

Is this fair?

It is hard to say if this trade is fair, because the rarities of the pets have not been revealed yet. I personally would not take this trade, as almost all of your pets are token trade-in pets and are likely to turn uncommon and rare.

Alright ^^ Thank you!

[Nosebleeds]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95099216&userid=955940&signature=1Ca4btkiwqriJ95NxkrQTA
I'm wondering if this is fair. Demand also taken into consideration.

[Rbpuppy]

Is this fair?

It is hard to say if this trade is fair, because the rarities of the pets have not been revealed yet. I personally would not take this trade, as almost all of your pets are token trade-in pets and are likely to turn uncommon and rare.

I second this and also advise that you wait until the rarities are determined for your pets. Most event pets usually turn into Rares if they’re token trade ins and if they all turn rare this will be very unfair to you.

[re4]

~ how does this look? thank you in advance!

this one too. ~

[shinx.]

is anyone able to give some advice with this?
thank you in advance! <3

[Camilo Madrigal]

Is this fair? this trade has 71 items from my WL [that i decently want] for all of my staff pets, that i worked pretty hard to get.

Opinions?