The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SilentOrchid]

Is this trade fair? Im very tentative with my very rares & I havent been online in a while,,

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95059365&userid=928872&signature=YacLOwI7q7U37S-XLakrIQ

[kmetott2014]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95039359&userid=18327&signature=8VsjQuXpzw4g8yjj3V6UbA

Can anyone help with this? I thought the UR B-Wolf and the Galaxy Cat were about equal in value which would mean there's some overpay on my side. Thank you in advance!

[Huskyflower]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94983172&userid=21889&signature=HQPmyTSCMTm2xDYCs2TrJw

Been a little while since I've been on this site lol, this seems like a good deal to me but are the scarves worth more than that now?

[MewSefet]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95057095&userid=262488&signature=aAkOi62Tf7X2Oh8fZHGwBA

I'm unsure if this is fair since the pets they want are event pets, which also don' have rarities yet

Unknown rarity pets are typically valued as an UC, so based on that it is unfair to you as they fit under the 3 month rule (until rarities are released). Event pets also have a bit high demand at the moment due to the event being active.

h. help
are these pets easy to trade off?? is this fair?

got a response that their store pets were low advents and only added up to 2.5 MA and 2 09' rares while my dragon is 3-4 MA's.
i'm not sure about the worth of those store pets/couldn't find them on a list(?)

could I have a second opinion on this? thank you!

Red malk dragon is a low sept list (if you follow listx), from what I can find, it's typically valued at 14-23 09 rares/~2-2.5 mid advents (I would estimate a closer lowest point at 16 '09R)xx

The rerelease dog on their side = 1xMA (t7, ~8 '09 R), and 2014 store pets are valued at a low advent (~3-6 '09 R), which adds up to roughly 18 '09 rares (if you value a low advent at 3 '09R)

Summary (from my research): their side = ~18-27 '09 R, your side =~14-23 '09R, but I would potentially get a second opinion as it varies a lot from the other opinion you've got (I'm not sure where they got their info from)

Is this trade fair? Im very tentative with my very rares & I havent been online in a while,,

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=95059365&userid=928872&signature=YacLOwI7q7U37S-XLakrIQ

a 2015 store pet = ~ 2x '09 R, their pets add up to around 2x '09 R using the 2:1 rule. However, store pets typically have slightly higher demand and variation in values between players, and it may be hard to trade similar values of pets for the PPS store pet if you were looking at trading for it again in the future

[Thianna]

Hey guys, can you please let me know if this trade is fair? I have been out of the trading loop for eons now (‘:

[Disintegration]

h. help
are these pets easy to trade off?? is this fair?
got a response that their store pets were low advents and only added up to 2.5 MA and 2 09' rares while my dragon is 3-4 MA's.
i'm not sure about the worth of those store pets/couldn't find them on a list(?)

could I have a second opinion on this? thank you!

Red malk dragon is a low sept list (if you follow listx), from what I can find, it's typically valued at 14-23 09 rares/~2-2.5 mid advents (I would estimate a closer lowest point at 16 '09R)xx

The rerelease dog on their side = 1xMA (t7, ~8 '09 R), and 2014 store pets are valued at a low advent (~3-6 '09 R), which adds up to roughly 18 '09 rares (if you value a low advent at 3 '09R)

Summary (from my research): their side = ~18-27 '09 R, your side =~14-23 '09R, but I would potentially get a second opinion as it varies a lot from the other opinion you've got (I'm not sure where they got their info from)

alright. i'm still a little confused on this -
i followed horror's list, it said the dragon was a mid sept?

may i get another opinion on this?

[Gelée Nova]

Hello! Could I get anyone's opinion on this offer I sent? Last I checked the skelebun went around 10-12 nons, has this changed at all? How much more would I need to add if this is unfair to them?
Thanks in advance! <3

[whitedane]

Is this fair?

[Rbpuppy]

Is this fair?

This was unfair to you. Even if their pets became Rares your 2020 rare is actually a 2010 rare.

[MewSefet]

Hiya!

It this fair? trade 1


Also, little unsure about between year trading for store pets, and I know there is some demand variations, i just don't know what they are. Would this be a fair trade?

VR2018 store BW

FOR


R 2019 pps lion + regular lion (same litter)