The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Ari!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201405&userid=994729&signature=pcXn_go3I0PCU2MDsjZJNQ
fast

i know the other Carousel Horses are worth 2MA's so I'm assuming the same for the zebra one.
i cant find a value for the spelltag kitsune either but I know the black one goes for 2MA's.
earth day deer is worth around 2 '09 rares, I couldn't find anything about the mother nature one.
because these are the values of not the specific store pets in this trade I would take this with a grain of salt and wait for another opinion, plus some of the values might be a little bit off

[_Eleanor_]

Could I please get help for his one?
I would be offering more Uncommons and older pets, but they'd offer a larger amount of pets. Is the trade fair? Or should I ask for less or more? Thank you in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201318&userid=1017271&signature=kcnnS_HUrbtXJ_DcCUMEbg

[Ari!]

Could I please get help for his one?
I would be offering more Uncommons and older pets, but they'd offer a larger amount of pets. Is the trade fair? Or should I ask for less or more? Thank you in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201318&userid=1017271&signature=kcnnS_HUrbtXJ_DcCUMEbg

Very unfair to you. something to keep in mind when trading is the 2:1 rule which a lot of people (but not all) go by. the idea is that 2 pets with the same rarity (and sometimes species), from the same year, are worth 1 pet of the same rarity from the year below. eg 2 2013 uncommons are worth 2 2012 uncommons. this goes for the same with rairties wjthin years. eg two commons from the same year is worth 1 uncommon from the other year; 2 very commons is worth 1 common etc.
you don't have to follow this rule, but it can be helpful with determining "fairness".
(:

[Booplesnoott]

May I ask for some help with this trade please ? I'm not sure at all if it's fair or not >.<

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94193759&userid=1009426&signature=sY9OrWrTF9qnw_c59zbsvQ

Thanks in advance !

Anyone ? ;u;

[kanade yoisaki]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201262&userid=974084&signature=lpJOWvYPO2I4YNV7zhYmfg

need a bit of help figuring out the worth of the other side ^^

[Ilovesmoothies!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94164243&userid=75661&signature=Gtyfr6Of_40DevdQszOSeA

How is this? Thanks!

And this please
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94163834&userid=75661&signature=hnjE5qNAamm38d7uFBsgeQ

Any help would be very much appreciated!

[Ari!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201262&userid=974084&signature=lpJOWvYPO2I4YNV7zhYmfg

need a bit of help figuring out the worth of the other side ^^

Swirl Valentines PPS mid october, same as Pointy Pink Pastel, together roughly worth 7 '09 rares
a late 2018 store pet is equal to an early 2010 rare.
plus '09 pet
to round it up, id say their side is worth 8.5 '09 rares

[AlexBlu]

Just checking on this ^^" a bit sleep deprived and want someone a little more clearer headed to make sure both sides are fair <3 thank you in advance!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201304&userid=291429&signature=2tXCMQzP5umMCt11RyA0UQ

not gonna add it all up but looks a bit unfair to you using the 2:1 rule

I edited it to what they had available to make it what I believe would be fair ^^" anyone able to help out on the edited version below?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201517&userid=291429&signature=y1mjmNcB8vTkaPk4eJFPBA

[Ari!]

Just checking on this ^^" a bit sleep deprived and want someone a little more clearer headed to make sure both sides are fair <3 thank you in advance!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201304&userid=291429&signature=2tXCMQzP5umMCt11RyA0UQ

not gonna add it all up but looks a bit unfair to you using the 2:1 rule

I edited it to what they had available to make it what I believe would be fair ^^" anyone able to help out on the edited version below?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94201517&userid=291429&signature=y1mjmNcB8vTkaPk4eJFPBA

you have 2.5 2012 uncommons while they have one (the two 2012 owls on their side = 1 unc). Their 2011 dog is worth your common owl. They have a quite a few 2014 uncommons on their side which is good. All six of them equal 1.5 2012 uncommons. Therefore you've broke even on that front. Your two 2015 and one 2014 uncommon equal a 2013 uncommon which is on their side. From there on out I would say that the other pets in the trade roughly even out on both sides (probably not perfectly). If you prefer bulk pets it wouldn't be a bad trade to accept.

[AlexBlu]

you have 2.5 2012 uncommons while they have one (the two 2012 owls on their side = 1 unc). Their 2011 dog is worth your common owl. They have a quite a few 2014 uncommons on their side which is good. All six of them equal 1.5 2012 uncommons. Therefore you've broke even on that front. Your two 2015 and one 2014 uncommon equal a 2013 uncommon which is on their side. From there on out I would say that the other pets in the trade roughly even out on both sides (probably not perfectly). If you prefer bulk pets it wouldn't be a bad trade to accept.

Awesome! Surprised I managed to edit it to equal it out so well being sleep deprived XD

Thank you ^^