The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Ari!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94048001&userid=1016753&signature=8p_P3JIpItFWk2D3FS8byg
is this fair? what is my store pet worth?

very unfair to you. just using C$ conversion rates, you pet is worth around 50C$ while each of their pets is only worth 8C$

[KookyAlienQueen]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94048001&userid=1016753&signature=8p_P3JIpItFWk2D3FS8byg
is this fair? what is my store pet worth?

very unfair to you. just using C$ conversion rates, you pet is worth around 50C$ while each of their pets is only worth 8C$

How do your work out c$ conversion rates?

[Ari!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94048001&userid=1016753&signature=8p_P3JIpItFWk2D3FS8byg
is this fair? what is my store pet worth?

very unfair to you. just using C$ conversion rates, you pet is worth around 50C$ while each of their pets is only worth 8C$

How do your work out c$ conversion rates?

I use this thread here
Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3915876

[Nala5]

Hi, guys!
I need help with one big trade (155 for 75 pets).
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93981496&userid=29292&signature=wcJkJKuDx5Trg7B-ErPglQ
From my calculations this trade should be an overpay from my side, but could someone please agree/disagree on this cuz I'm not 100% sure?

just from looking at it it looks like your side is over, and thats accounting for the 2018 pets too (very roughly making 1 2018 store = 1 2009 rare).
i would decline

That's what I thought. Thanks! <3

[spongegrass]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94048101&userid=1010678&signature=IlHFuYAbnU1n7D2V9A3cIw

[Redbird]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94042999&userid=27822&signature=_4NXfv4FulDdkD5svwDafA
Any updated data on angel wings and Malk fairies? I'm aware of the item value thread but that hasn't been updated in years, and so much has changed in the last 1-2 years.

[Redbird]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94048101&userid=1010678&signature=IlHFuYAbnU1n7D2V9A3cIw

Technically unfair to them. The spider alone would be fair/overpay for your side, but many people are willing to overpay for PPS lions so that's probably why they added extra.

[Annabeth00]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94048206&userid=345279&signature=EiXrOWe7Iki-6P9GSJaV9A

Is this fair? Don't know too much about items

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94048206&userid=345279&signature=EiXrOWe7Iki-6P9GSJaV9A

Is this fair? Don't know too much about items

that's a lot of low-value pets, and it's hard to apply a direct value to them.

Your swords are each worth at least one 2011 uncommon each (they're 2013 items but I'm basing this on what I've seen them go for); probably a bit more than that. If you value them at a 2011 rare each, the trade is unfair to you. If you value them at a 2011 uncommon each, it's basically fair from what I'm seeing. If you value them somewhere in between it's probably still fair.

Overall this trade is hard because low-value pets are value what they're worth to the trader. I do think the quantity helps increase the value here and makes it okay for each side.

[ahirked]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=94048206&userid=345279&signature=EiXrOWe7Iki-6P9GSJaV9A

Is this fair? Don't know too much about items

that's a lot of low-value pets, and it's hard to apply a direct value to them.

Your swords are each worth at least one 2011 uncommon each (they're 2013 items but I'm basing this on what I've seen them go for); probably a bit more than that. If you value them at a 2011 rare each, the trade is unfair to you. If you value them at a 2011 uncommon each, it's basically fair from what I'm seeing. If you value them somewhere in between it's probably still fair.

Overall this trade is hard because low-value pets are value what they're worth to the trader. I do think the quantity helps increase the value here and makes it okay for each side.

the swords are from the 2013 slumber party event. imo these particular ones are very easy to come by so I'd stick to valuing them at a 2013 uncommon ea.