The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kqt_scratch]

I'm not super sure if this is fair on my end, but I want to make sure beforehand since I'm not very knowing with rares, etc.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94044369&userid=908566&signature=fKHZCI_ISoEUS0m51uM8bA

Still need help on this one! And I'm unsure as to if this is fair either, I'm not familiar with c$ values
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94047143&userid=908566&signature=GOp9lRlCwNhbeB4bzm_htA

[KookyAlienQueen]

hi is this fair.
I don't think it is however I want to double check
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94046969&userid=1016753&signature=Y5vzLZOd0L8UbdGmsgycww

[Ari!]

hi is this fair.
I don't think it is however I want to double check
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94046969&userid=1016753&signature=Y5vzLZOd0L8UbdGmsgycww

I would say thats fair to you. If using the 2:1 rule they'd be over paying. (two commons of the same year = 1 uncommon, 2 uncommon = 1 rare etc.)

[Ari!]

I'm not super sure if this is fair on my end, but I want to make sure beforehand since I'm not very knowing with rares, etc.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94044369&userid=908566&signature=fKHZCI_ISoEUS0m51uM8bA

Still need help on this one! And I'm unsure as to if this is fair either, I'm not familiar with c$ values
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94047143&userid=908566&signature=GOp9lRlCwNhbeB4bzm_htA

technically, the first trade you have there is fair, but I reckon you could get more for the scorpion.
second trade is unfair to you
"A 2010 rare/very rare is worth around 25-40C$", if you need help with c$ rarities use this guide, its very useful.
I would value your pet at the 40C$, because I believe its a staff pet, and on top of that it's a dog, (you might even be able to get more for it).
What they're offering is 15C$, plus those other pets, which I would value around 17C$ (this is very rough, some people would value them lower/higher, me personally would value them a little bit lower, maybe 15C$?), so altogether adds to roughly 30-32C$.
Therefore I would say is unfair to you

[☼find your wings☼]

I really love the BA but I'm unsure!

[Sweetfrog]

How’s this non wise? I got about 10 in my rough count!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=94042448&userid=633510&signature=j810HxT4Uy5VYu4ThIXPZQ

I’d love some advice!:))

[blurry_cat1]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94045270&userid=994729&signature=hA63M52i2DLwTjQ_yruHSA
My bid

Okay nvm, sunback is worth something like 2-3 nons but how many my side is worth?

[Nala5]

Hi, guys!
I need help with one big trade (155 for 75 pets).
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93981496&userid=29292&signature=wcJkJKuDx5Trg7B-ErPglQ
From my calculations this trade should be an overpay from my side, but could someone please agree/disagree on this cuz I'm not 100% sure?

[KookyAlienQueen]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=94048001&userid=1016753&signature=8p_P3JIpItFWk2D3FS8byg
is this fair? what is my store pet worth?

[Ari!]

Hi, guys!
I need help with one big trade (155 for 75 pets).
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93981496&userid=29292&signature=wcJkJKuDx5Trg7B-ErPglQ
From my calculations this trade should be an overpay from my side, but could someone please agree/disagree on this cuz I'm not 100% sure?

just from looking at it it looks like your side is over, and thats accounting for the 2018 pets too (very roughly making 1 2018 store = 1 2009 rare).
i would decline