The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Sali]

Again I need help with this trade.
So I think someone said their side adds up to 4 non‘s if I‘m right?
Would the Eat me alone be fair for all pets on their side?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93258428&userid=273533&signature=aNkUNXXVjaDfLKMg5xM51Q

[b.umblebee]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93441691&userid=903339&signature=lSidYRKAiK-RN82vSLgMIQ

how does this look? im not familiar with item values

[heaven.]

hello! is this a fair trade?

trade link

[Bingus]

any advice on which one i should accept?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93428205&userid=361577&signature=nXAaVTFtm-HYVqFPRmho2w
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93429278&userid=361577&signature=Fs6vuI1R-09JoYd7JW8YWw

thanks for any help!

for the second one they asked for an under trade so id let them know that what they asked for is under for those giraffes correct if im wrong but i think each giraffe may be a 2010 rare? ill have to check on that

[~Sunlight~]

any advice on which one i should accept?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93428205&userid=361577&signature=nXAaVTFtm-HYVqFPRmho2w
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93429278&userid=361577&signature=Fs6vuI1R-09JoYd7JW8YWw

thanks for any help!

for the second one they asked for an under trade so id let them know that what they asked for is under for those giraffes correct if im wrong but i think each giraffe may be a 2010 rare? ill have to check on that

I think you sent that trade. For next time remember that a newer store pet is worth a 2010 rare just like they said!
Oops just saw that it they sent the trade on that one so I would ask them about that! I'm not sure about the first one!

[TheBrokenRobot]

Thoughts anyone?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93438713&userid=960078&signature=BgG00LUj4Q8oaF94hFeKtQ

Thank you

[mochahearts]

Hello! I have theses bids for a Blue Toxic are any of theses trades fair? Thank you
- # 1

- # 2

-# 3

-# 4

-# 5

-# 6

[Denidene]

Heya, would this be fair? If not what should be added?
Any help would be appreciated <3

[creaky bones]

a '21 store pet is worth a '10 rare, right? not a 2009 very rare?

[Tail & Kaybird]

Any help with this? I'm not very good with store pet rarities.