The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[venti]

link here
Can someone help me? I'm not sure of this pets worth, as I haven't been on long enough to learn of the new demands!

please do not accept that.
liontails tend to go for 2-2.5 nons
the target dog is at least 2-3 mas

[Mewfles]

link here
Can someone help me? I'm not sure of this pets worth, as I haven't been on long enough to learn of the new demands!

Very unfair to the liontail. They go for 2- 2,5 nons

link here
Can someone help me? I'm not sure of this pets worth, as I haven't been on long enough to learn of the new demands!

the liontail is worth around 2.5 nons
the target dog is only 2ma, so it's highly unfair to you

Ty both, I've been a bit hesitant towards trades involving my higher end rarity pets as I haven't been on long enough to know the new demand for these!

[Bonsai]

link here
Can someone help me? I'm not sure of this pets worth, as I haven't been on long enough to learn of the new demands!

hi mew ! i sent you this trade ! i wasnt offering the target dog alone if you read the sent message i ask what you are looking to trade your liontail for! i just had to send a pet in the trade since hes wishlist only ( just so you you !! ) <3

[.muse.]

Not sure of the 2009 Halloween Lil Monsters worth

[Karcrab]

This is someone's bid, opinions?

Please if anyone could give an opinion

[|Be happy]

hi all!

please let me know if this is fair? are those ponies high demand?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93372860&userid=104271&signature=8kqJGmGRahVPjEZ5Yk77Rw

[skunksmell]

Thoughts? Which side would you rather have?
Also, how much is blue ice rat going for these days? Thank you so much! c:
I value the llama store pet as a mid to high advent.

[ahirked]

Not sure of the 2009 Halloween Lil Monsters worth

I believe I traded an 09 rare for the halloween lil monster, but unfortunately I cannot find the trade link. generally speaking, I'd put it at an 09 rare/very rare, perhaps more so the latter value seeing as it seems fairly scarce to come by.
that said, there is next to no information about this item. the only indication I can find is the cs items guide's consideration of valuing it at a late 09 rare back in 2013 (see here). arguably the value would have gone up somewhat since then, I'd hazard anyway!

as for the wings, if you scroll to the bottom of my response here, I estimated the value of each retired store item at a 2012 uncommon ea.

personally I think this trade is a good deal. my only hesitance would be the lacking information regarding the lil monster. if you do go ahead with this trade, I'd recommend posting it on the items trades thread as a guide/semi-indicator to other users!

[Laetificat]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93332505&userid=596560&signature=MCz1fR9IR3jCrWh0e0Rxng
Please help

[Kabuski]

hi all!

please let me know if this is fair? are those ponies high demand?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93372860&userid=104271&signature=8kqJGmGRahVPjEZ5Yk77Rw

They’re pretty avg demand but nonetheless this is unfair to you, their side is worth a 2018 rare
Your side is worth at least 2 09’s

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=93332505&userid=596560&signature=MCz1fR9IR3jCrWh0e0Rxng
Please help

The pet on your side is an October list and is worth 3-4 09’s or 150 c$
Their side is a t6 (on the og list) which is worth 6.5 09 rares, so rarity wise this is unfair to them
Demand wise your side *can* get up to an ma as it does have good demand, but this truly how both sides value the pets!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93331009&userid=725461&signature=zwj2ADPGunYYglnKuPm6Aw
please help <3 and if its not fair, how much C$ or pets would they need to add?

This is overpay on their part, none of the items are your side has significant worth except the koi, deer and duck items since they are sought after
Plushies have pretty good demand as well but they’re still worth an uncommon of the same year they’re released
If you were to add it up it could be worth around an 09 rare just unfortunately I don’t know all the years on the top of my head so this is really going to be up for self-evaluation - whether you rather have their pets or your items

Tl;dr
In my personal opinion they’re overpaying, but everyone values items differently, the items in general though would be worth an uncommon from the year they’re released