The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Cøpacetic]

Quick opinions please? I dunno what my bat is worth
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92641067&userid=881527&signature=tbHW_34w4RDeKIZC2Q-DvA

[Starcollie]

Advice on this one please?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92641135&userid=794136&signature=e6vh6SYSof5Kad1nYsEQfg

I was hesitant to trade them away but I liked this offer ^^

very unfair to you
grapes are around 0.5
rainbow main is 1 non
the c$ and odd pets don't equate to much

your joker is around 2 nons
and their side is around 1.5

i agree with han please dont accept that the grapes demand has dropped drastically too and my friends who own grapes have been really really stuggling to trade them away you could get way way more for a joker

Oops... whelp 😩

[FOUND VERDICT]

Advice on this one please?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92641135&userid=794136&signature=e6vh6SYSof5Kad1nYsEQfg

I was hesitant to trade them away but I liked this offer ^^

very unfair to you
grapes are around 0.5
rainbow main is 1 non
the c$ and odd pets don't equate to much

your joker is around 2 nons
and their side is around 1.5

i agree with han please dont accept that the grapes demand has dropped drastically too and my friends who own grapes have been really really stuggling to trade them away you could get way way more for a joker

the joker IS NOT 2 nons, i have no idea where that value came from? only true dates sometimes fetch that much.
grapes have neutral demand and are relatively easy to swap for an sorb/sorb worth pets. rainbow mane seems to be a bit under an non after the rarity change. all in all definitely not a bad trade for the joker

[kapetrovaa]

the joker IS NOT 2 nons, i have no idea where that value came from? only true dates sometimes fetch that much.
grapes have neutral demand and are relatively easy to swap for an sorb/sorb worth pets. rainbow mane seems to be a bit under an non after the rarity change. all in all definitely not a bad trade for the joker

unfortunately, this just isn't true
recent trade data shows the "demand" for the joker has raised over the 1.5 nons of value, leaving it to be warranted around 2
the grapes are actually unimaginably hard to trade off, even for a swap to a sorb

this unfortunately just wasn't a good offer

[Bonsai]

the joker IS NOT 2 nons, i have no idea where that value came from? only true dates sometimes fetch that much.
grapes have neutral demand and are relatively easy to swap for an sorb/sorb worth pets. rainbow mane seems to be a bit under an non after the rarity change. all in all definitely not a bad trade for the joker[/quote][/quote]

i mean the joker just is worth 2 non tho i personally value him at 1.5 when not a TD but at the end of the day that just is what its trading for hence why everyone including me has said that i think i dont think quite a few pets are worth what they are trading for rn but its the way it is , i wouldnt trade any of my pets 2 nons worth for a joker but thats all i have seen him trading for recently td or not and i havent seen a single trade where he has gone for less than 2 non on all the threads too and people are obviously willing to offer this amount for him so wether we agree that its right or not that just is what hes being traded for currently and what hes worth also maybe youve had a great experience with the grapes but it took me over 5 weeks to even get a fair offer when i had them and i had a terrible time owning them i did not enjoy it at all and from the people i know who currently own grapes and from posts on forums they are finding it extreamly hard to get rid of them also but thats just my personal experience owning them

[FOUND VERDICT]

the joker IS NOT 2 nons, i have no idea where that value came from? only true dates sometimes fetch that much.
grapes have neutral demand and are relatively easy to swap for an sorb/sorb worth pets. rainbow mane seems to be a bit under an non after the rarity change. all in all definitely not a bad trade for the joker

unfortunately, this just isn't true
recent trade data shows the "demand" for the joker has raised a over the 1.5 nons of value, leaving it to be warranted around 2
the grapes are actually unimaginably hard to trade off, even for a swap to a sorb

this unfortunately just wasn't a good offer

i don't think i've ever traded grapes for anything elss than sorb value, even recently and i owned a lot of them. they really aren't "unimaginably hard" to trade off if you have a little patience ^^"

there really is no need to push the joker to 2 nons in my opinion, but to each their own i guess.

[TransgenderTabby]

the joker IS NOT 2 nons, i have no idea where that value came from? only true dates sometimes fetch that much.
grapes have neutral demand and are relatively easy to swap for an sorb/sorb worth pets. rainbow mane seems to be a bit under an non after the rarity change. all in all definitely not a bad trade for the joker

[/quote]

i mean the joker just is worth 2 non tho i personally value him at 1.5 when not a TD but at the end of the day that just is what its trading for hence why everyone including me has said that i think i dont think quite a few pets are worth what they are trading for rn but its the way it is , i wouldnt trade any of my pets 2 nons worth for a joker but thats all i have seen him trading for recently td or not and i havent seen a single trade where he has gone for less than 2 non on all the threads too and people are obviously willing to offer this amount for him so wether we agree that its right or not that just is what hes being traded for currently and what hes worth also maybe youve had a great experience with the grapes but it took me over 5 weeks to even get a fair offer when i had them and i had a terrible time owning them i did not enjoy it at all and from the people i know who currently own grapes and from posts on forums they are finding it extreamly hard to get rid of them also but thats just my personal experience owning them[/quote]

The joker isn’t worth 2 nons. But, it is worth 1 to 1.5 nons. That’s what it’s worth in general but your always free to value it at your own price!

[Howl's Moving Castle]

the joker IS NOT 2 nons, i have no idea where that value came from? only true dates sometimes fetch that much.
grapes have neutral demand and are relatively easy to swap for an sorb/sorb worth pets. rainbow mane seems to be a bit under an non after the rarity change. all in all definitely not a bad trade for the joker

unfortunately, this just isn't true
recent trade data shows the "demand" for the joker has raised a over the 1.5 nons of value, leaving it to be warranted around 2
the grapes are actually unimaginably hard to trade off, even for a swap to a sorb

this unfortunately just wasn't a good offer

i don't think i've ever traded grapes for anything elss than sorb value, even recently and i owned a lot of them. they really aren't "unimaginably hard" to trade off if you have a little patience ^^"

there really is no need to push the joker to 2 nons in my opinion, but to each their own i guess.

i got 2 nons worth a couple months back when i held a joker auction, i think you can get 2 but its hard to get 2

Edit: it was 2 months back, ba TD is 1.5, balloon is .5 + adds
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91997734&userid=985794&signature=bQthdRdBFK8UhjlE5Y9cfA

i think i got lucky with the bid but im just gonna point out i have had it happen to me where a crazy joker fan overed for my joker for a auction

[Bonsai]

the joker IS NOT 2 nons, i have no idea where that value came from? only true dates sometimes fetch that much.
grapes have neutral demand and are relatively easy to swap for an sorb/sorb worth pets. rainbow mane seems to be a bit under an non after the rarity change. all in all definitely not a bad trade for the joker

The joker isn’t worth 2 nons. But, it is worth 1 to 1.5 nons. That’s what it’s worth in general but your always free to value it at your own price![/quote]

i think its moving rapidly in value and demand but this situation happens with many different pets when their value is changing where nobody agrees on the value , nobody is ever going to agree totally on what pets are worth and i know nobody here is but alot of people get salty on pets worth increasing and hate to accept it , i agree with you that everyone is intitled to their own opinion but on this thread you are meant to help people and even if you value the joker at 1 non like you said thats just not true and i woudlnt encourage people to trade theirs for that value ever, everyone has different experiences owning pets like i said above i personally also value the joker at 1.5 i disagree very harshly with it being worth 1 non as you said before i would never ever get a trade of a joker and add for my UR holly or squid which is my point that at the end of the day if its not trading for anything less that 2 non you cant say its not worth that , this is the lowest trade ive seen the joker go for in a long long time whether i agree with that or not you cant just say its not worth that when thats the offers its going for now days

[Cøpacetic]

Quick opinions please? I dunno what my bat is worth
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92641067&userid=881527&signature=tbHW_34w4RDeKIZC2Q-DvA