The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[loppy555]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87588704&userid=712675&signature=9tHEvsoufjZ_gN6qcvq9sA

[kapetrovaa]

hello!
could I please have an opinion
or two on this trade please?
thank you

[EchothroughDarkness]

Was this fair??

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92590087&userid=410864&signature=qzxRdFKSOGTHaBN8jPFfWQ

[rhaenyra]

this?

[Pipsquawk]

can I get some help on this? Im not too sure what the dragoncat goes for at this point

[☽isa☾]

I'm pretty sure that this is around fair with demand, right?
thank you!!!
edit:
this one too! thank you!
this one as well

[Howl's Moving Castle]

hello!
could I please have an opinion
or two on this trade please?
thank you

i think you can get much more for the full set, the irl dog set tends to get alot for the litter mates alone. im not sure what the full woth would be for the full set but this is unfair to you.

this?

their over date wise, your items are newer

can I get some help on this? Im not too sure what the dragoncat goes for at this point

thats a okay offer, recently cat dragon has been getting 3-4 ma's your offering about 4 so you be paying the max

I'm pretty sure that this is around fair with demand, right?
thank you!!!
edit:
this one too! thank you!
this one as well

1 vs 2, i think 1 is the better offer since warriors are popular and thier asking for less then the 2nd trade
for the 3rd one i would say its unfair to your brown aussie pps

Is this fair? I know the Valentines malk pps usually goes for more then a regular 09 vr but what does the zombie pony go for?

Also 2 more offers came in:
Peppermint Bun & Peppermint BW for PPS malk Valentines & Blue Fairy

Blue Main Horse (from RBM litter) & 2012 Store Kirin (?) for PPS malk Valentines and Grown malk Valentines

Are either of these fair? Any help would be awesome, thank you!

1: unfair to you, malk pps can get a T4-T7 advent and ponies are such low demand
3: unfair to you as well since horses are lower demand then malks

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92583550&userid=725461&signature=Z-IajSAgY4peKf5qaT-qpQ

also they said this when i asked them to add:

im sorry i get that yours are from a earlier date but i have 4 pets on here and one of your pets is only an omg so common and the uncommon is getting offered 3 pets so its rllu up to u to cancel or accept!

Date wise this is extremely unfair to you.

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87588704&userid=712675&signature=9tHEvsoufjZ_gN6qcvq9sA

i personally wouldn't take this. UR rat is low demand and rarely gets its full value so you would be able to get your worth back, and the C$ doesn't add or help too much.

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92590553&userid=119355&signature=ZuQJrcf-DkOiP3TD3ixfyw

extremely unfair to them
your side doesn't even equal their storepet

their very over, the 2017 store pet is worth more then your side alone.

[kapetrovaa]

hello!
could I please have an opinion
or two on this trade please?
thank you

i think you can get much more for the full set, the irl dog set tends to get alot for the litter mates alone. im not sure what the full woth would be for the full set but this is unfair to you.

thank you so much
does anyone know what they can fetch please?

[JayJay]

Is this fair? I know the Valentines malk pps usually goes for more then a regular 09 vr but what does the zombie pony go for?

Also 2 more offers came in:
Peppermint Bun & Peppermint BW for PPS malk Valentines & Blue Fairy

Blue Main Horse (from RBM litter) & 2012 Store Kirin (?) for PPS malk Valentines and Grown malk Valentines

Are either of these fair? Any help would be awesome, thank you!

[Frozen_Cherry]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92583550&userid=725461&signature=Z-IajSAgY4peKf5qaT-qpQ

also they said this when i asked them to add:

im sorry i get that yours are from a earlier date but i have 4 pets on here and one of your pets is only an omg so common and the uncommon is getting offered 3 pets so its rllu up to u to cancel or accept!