The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Howl's Moving Castle]

Are these fair?
#1
#2

1. fair swap both from 2009
2. C$ over

[greenbunny1998]

Is this trade fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92113956&userid=615201&signature=c4rGFxmXtmevYaEbKTXblg
If not what would either need to add? in C$ and non c$ maybe

[Assassins]

Would either of these be fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92110310&userid=744505&signature=pDedR_I7dN2fOHfNjtLm_w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92026499&userid=744505&signature=M5mbpwA6mPsiMz58Nr_jow

1st Trade: Using the 2021 values , your 2013 corgi storepet is worth a mid-advent, which go for around 200-250C$. I personally value 2010 rares at 20-25c$, and the 09' VR PPS dog at 60c$, so using the minimums (200 + 20 + 20 + 60) it comes to exactly, 300 c$!

This is a fair trade in my opinion and I would take it.

The second is unfair to you c$ wise & pet wise.

( Resources: LufikER, the condensed rarity thread )

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92113210&userid=1001373&signature=lmCxQ_wa6_Uy828BNOPD8w

Is this fair? An slightly unsure

Unfair to you / I wouldn't take it ! Your Butterfly Wolf PPS Rare is actually from http://www.chickensmoothie.com/archive/2013/May/Butterfly%20wolfMay%202013!

Thank you! <3

[uro]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92113181&userid=741998&signature=SvXp2ZQBi1r79TVMaNzY2A

which has better demand?

[Vanish]

So I know C$ wise a rare store pet and a very rare store pet are worth the same amount of C$, but is it fair if you just trade a rare store pet for a very rare store pet with nothing added? The majority of people I've asked said a very rare store pet is worth more, so if this is the case, how much more?

I personally value them the same if they're from the same year.
The rare ones were bought more because they are more popular.
So, it balances out.

Thanks! Could I get some second opinions? (They can just be personal opinions)

Chiming in for my own pennies:
( Trying to simplify it / i'm not good with explaining ! )

From what I've seen, it's absolutely up to preference & what each person is striving for- maybe it's for a hoard, or a collection, in which case it usually doesn't matter. Rarity wise, yes the tag shows rare/VR, but it's not that much big of a value gap due to the fact theyre storepets ((and that the rare could be on the very tip of the slider to where it'd count as a VR and vice versa)), and on a technical level, all of them will turn VR eventually due to never being re-released / increasing in population after they stop being sold.

TDLR; a lot of the time it really doesn't matter & it personally hasn't affected my trading at all.
Personal preference, year, and the popularity of the storepet is what matter usually. Otherwise, the VR storepet being valuable is more up to the person.

Hope this helps / gives you a bit more insight !

Thank you! <3

No problem !

[세레비]

Thank you for the previous advice, what about this bid? And, would you pick it over this bid?

[CalicoWolf]

Would a Joker for a UR Marshmallow/Smore be a fair trade?

[☽isa☾]

Would a Joker for a UR Marshmallow/Smore be a fair trade?

the new urs are worth 1-2.5 nons and really fluctuate depending on who you trade with. the joker should be fair for it though, because it is in the range (1.5 nons). the ur foods tend to decrease in value, so I feel like it would be overpaying to offer the higher end, so 1.5 nons should be good.

[Deerdancer]

Can't tell if this is fair. Please help. Thank you.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92114077&userid=203847&signature=IvwkFcsvMwLY8NeWLL3LaA

[greenbunny1998]

Can't tell if this is fair. Please help. Thank you.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92114077&userid=203847&signature=IvwkFcsvMwLY8NeWLL3LaA

Not fair on the 2011 rare