The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[KnownAsAFangirl]

Hi.
Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92104270&userid=725458&signature=p9N7kEh2iV2wDE9r8EyN-A

Thanks

[PastelCupid]

help! is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92104312&userid=736952&signature=q6-rBFS5oaIrQVs3D-6j3A

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92104169&userid=736952&signature=zKHSkN3AAdhyfDspfXAjUg

[PastelDog]

Hey would this be fair 4 2010 VR bats= Cheshire store set + 100 C$? Am I overpaying or underpaying? If either what's needs to be added? Thank you.

[SkyeInfern0]

Hi, can I get help with my Zodiac auction. Which ones are the best?

Bid for all six

Bid for two

Bid for one

Bid for one

Bid for one

Thank you in advance

And this
Bid for one

[Deerdancer]

Is this fair? Very confused. Please and thank you.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92100016&userid=203847&signature=n7ezP-K_ZV2do3oIuG_BGQ

[Misty Hills]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92105038&userid=1003656&signature=ltJ52EMYY7EdsCkQhVR29w

Is this fair?

[ThunderCedar]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92105038&userid=1003656&signature=ltJ52EMYY7EdsCkQhVR29w

Is this fair?

They are overpaying
Your pet is a mid 2010 rare
Their pets are worth 1 late 2010 rare each. One of their store pets should be replaced with a 2010 uncommon or so to make the trade fair.

[KnownAsAFangirl]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92105038&userid=1003656&signature=ltJ52EMYY7EdsCkQhVR29w

Is this fair?

I would say this is very unfair to you. Your pink dog is a rerelease from June 2010, so is worth a lot more than 2020 pets (Even store pets). I'm not sure exactly how much your guy is worth- though it is definitely more than is being offered.
I hope you are having a lovely day/night!


EDIT: I've just read the other reply. Interesting to know the store pets worth! I guess it comes down to what you personally like- I obviously have more of a love of the earlier pets!

[This Is Halloween]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92105038&userid=1003656&signature=ltJ52EMYY7EdsCkQhVR29w

Is this fair?

I would say this is very unfair to you. Your pink dog is a rerelease from June 2010, so is worth a lot more than 2020 pets (Even store pets). I'm not sure exactly how much your guy is worth- though it is definitely more than is being offered.
I hope you are having a lovely day/night!

I’d have to disagree. Store pets value will go up as time goes on. technically they’re overpaying with one of the store pets. Overall it’s unfair to your trading partners side.

[ahirked]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92105038&userid=1003656&signature=ltJ52EMYY7EdsCkQhVR29w

Is this fair?

I would say this is very unfair to you. Your pink dog is a rerelease from June 2010, so is worth a lot more than 2020 pets (Even store pets). I'm not sure exactly how much your guy is worth- though it is definitely more than is being offered.
I hope you are having a lovely day/night!

disagree with this. 2020 stores are worth a late-2010 rare, so I'd argue the top side is overpaying since they are offering two store pets which both equate to two late 2010 rares.