The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[loservenue]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92068917&userid=920031&signature=mFNLoqDy8zj0AkyEiN_bTg
this?

[graec]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92069351&userid=896108&signature=S0aT5Oi1NtNkmmY1zV4kYw

pls someone help me lol thank u

[kayyye]

can i get some help with this trade please? :>
ty!!♡kayyye
edit: this too please! :>

Your pet is actually a straight non, though I got it confused with a dogtag too!

oooh ty!
which trade would be better then?

[panda:3]

I have these that I would love help with if anyone has a second ❤️
1
2
3 Here they said ‘ Alternatively the Balloon and Sorb can be taken out for the Banana’
4 They aren’t asking for all, they put ‘I added a green sorbet for a straight swap or the toxic + ma’s for a trade down’

Any advice would be great!! I’m hopeless! Thankyou ❤️

[Stress In A Box]

What do y’all think of this? They have the store pets at 1 MA each, so I think it’s fair for the Grinner but I’d like a second opinion as I’m new to list pets. Thank you in advance for any help!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92071398&userid=644087&signature=Om9oPR3EebOEXX630BX1FQ

[ThunderCedar]

I have these that I would love help with if anyone has a second ❤️
1
2

Any advice would be great!! I’m hopeless! Thankyou ❤️

1: their side adds up to a 2014 uncommon at most
The fireplace on your side is worth more than that alone as it is from 2011 christmas

2: That is big overpay on their side, the tinsel horse is an ex-list pet from 2008 christmas.
I have looked through several trades and cannot find any data on the deer fetching this much overpay, or much data at all for the matter. You may need a 2nd opinion on this one.

[KnownAsAFangirl]

Hi everyone.

Is this fair from either side?
Thanks

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92071539&userid=725458&signature=_n0hJs-b4tzgRBeoxqfkYQ

[panda:3]

I have these that I would love help with if anyone has a second ❤️
1
2

Any advice would be great!! I’m hopeless! Thankyou ❤️

1: their side adds up to a 2014 uncommon at most
The fireplace on your side is worth more than that alone as it is from 2011 christmas

2: That is big overpay on their side, the tinsel horse is an ex-list pet from 2008 christmas.
I have looked through several trades and cannot find any data on the deer fetching this much overpay, or much data at all for the matter. You may need a 2nd opinion on this one.

Thankyou so much for your reply ❤️

[Howl's Moving Castle]

can i get some help with this trade please? :>
ty!!♡kayyye
edit: this too please! :>

Your pet is actually a straight non, though I got it confused with a dogtag too!

oooh ty!
which trade would be better then?

2nd one is unfair to you, the sorb is half a no but the malk dragon is only worth 3 ma's max so this offering .75 nons for your pet a non

[throwawaynew]

help?
thank you so much!