The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[pochita]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92066526&userid=901300&signature=QrG_H-LfRbCZCB-_PzQ-SA
How’s this for my Sunback?

[GhostFaceッ]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92068922&userid=739856&signature=Zhzx1Fuyp9r7Uah3eJRcNw
has the ur bee's demand gone down at all since the rarity change? and is this fair?

edit: also got sent this
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92068955&userid=739856&signature=M501xhFQD2E8cQR1S3cK2g
help pls

[Dingo Berry]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92069608&userid=655723&signature=McCVhZ-I0mywFQS7rZW7jw

Is this fair to either side?

[kayyye]

can i get some help with this trade please? :>
ty!!♡kayyye
edit: this too please! :>

Not sure about this first one but in the case of the second unfair to you as the sorbet is 0.5 nons and the red dragon is a mid sept while your pet is between 1.5-2 nons

ty! any help with the first trade please?

[ChunkyChad]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92068922&userid=739856&signature=Zhzx1Fuyp9r7Uah3eJRcNw
has the ur bee's demand gone down at all since the rarity change? and is this fair?

edit: also got sent this
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92068955&userid=739856&signature=M501xhFQD2E8cQR1S3cK2g
help pls

(2nd trade idk about the first one sorry)
I think fair or slightly unfair to them
So Ive seen some saying that that the cat goes for around 2.5-2.75 nons
The punk goes for 0.5 same with the balloon, the patchwork is a bit in the air at the moment but 1-1.5 seems the standard(some go higher) which makes your side equal on the low end 2nons or higher end 2.5+nons. then the firework pps = 1 MA but Im bad at factoring those in to equations :c
Id recommend getting a second opinion incase my numbers are wrong^^

[pochita]

can i get some help with this trade please? :>
ty!!♡kayyye
edit: this too please! :>

Not sure about this first one but in the case of the second unfair to you as the sorbet is 0.5 nons and the red dragon is a mid sept while your pet is between 1.5-2 nons

ty! any help with the first trade please?

Your pet is actually a straight non, though I got it confused with a dogtag too!

[Tapedeck]

Alright boys, back again

Would this + Nick Unicorn + Pink Heart be getting close to the 1-3 Non gap between the Sun Jewel and Ur Tiger Dog ? How many rares am I lacking ?

(My Sunpup has officially reached 30 days and isn’t a non-jewel so I think it’s safe to assume)

[pochita]

Alright boys, back again

Would this + Nick Unicorn + Pink Heart be getting close to the 1-3 Non gap between the Sun Jewel and Ur Tiger Dog ? How many rares am I lacking ?

(My Sunpup has officially reached 30 days and isn’t a non-jewel so I think it’s safe to assume)

If you mean another sunjewel then 100% you’d close the gap with just the two of those. If you mean the group + a unickorn and a tier 7, I think it’d equal ~4.5 nons in total? Give it a second opinion though my math probably sucks

[GhostFaceッ]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92068922&userid=739856&signature=Zhzx1Fuyp9r7Uah3eJRcNw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92069742&userid=739856&signature=RHMH5F51Z9b0nPYcGzkPxQ
reposting these for more opinions, please consider demand in these, thank you for all previous opinions!
should i take either or keep my pets? thank you!

[Lennie]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92068922&userid=739856&signature=Zhzx1Fuyp9r7Uah3eJRcNw
has the ur bee's demand gone down at all since the rarity change? and is this fair?

edit: also got sent this
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92068955&userid=739856&signature=M501xhFQD2E8cQR1S3cK2g
help pls

it is unlikely that the ur bee's demand will be affected all too greatly by this, but it is a bit early to know for sure what the long term effects of this change will be ^^
first trade:
trade evidence for the ur bee (following dec. 18th) still suggests that the pet is fetching 2.5-3 nons in trades x
so valuing their side @ 2.5-3 nons (250-450 '09 rares)
// your side - tufted blood dog [6-7 '09 rares x x] + pink punk [0.5 nons/1 sorb x] + patchwork [1-1.5 nons, more consistent @ 1.5 x] + firework pps [by rarity worth up to a MA x] + dark leopard [2 MA x] + pink balloon [0.5 nons/1 sorb x]
low end estimate, your side = 228 '09 rares / high end estimate, your side = 324 '09 rares
or THEM: 2.5-3 nons versus YOURS: ~2.5-3 nons

second trade:
the ur (tess) cat seems to consistently fetch 2.5 nons, though some trade evidence suggests the value is closer to 2.5-3 nons x (making it quite similar to the ur bee)
again valuing their side @ 2.5-3 nons
// your side - pink punk [0.5 nons/1 sorb] + patchwork [1-1.5 nons] + firework pps [up to a MA by rarity] + pink balloon [0.5 nons/1 sorb]
low end estimate, your side = just over 2 nons / high end estimate, your side = just over 2.5 nons
or THEM: 2.5-3 nons versus YOURS: ~2-2.5 nons

neither trade is particularly unfair, though I agree with ChunkyChad that the second trade would be closer to fair/slight overpay on their side. it would ultimately come down to which pets you prefer after considering the trading values as such c:
also, in both cases, the patchwork is likely to be valued closer to 1.5 nons so I would lean towards the higher estimate than the lower with that in mind ^^