The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Mykie]

could i get a couple opinions?
I'm trying to auction off the rat for quantity and this is the best offer i've gotten so far?

I just got this one as well, which would be worth more?

[ahirked]

would this trade be fair?
xxx

the angel wings are a current store item, worth 2.5c$ on its own
your 2014 uncommon is worth 6-7c$ on it's own, so definitely unfair to you

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91896878&userid=979673&signature=Z_3kHFezsEKEnpA9wKPa5w
Hi, this is a very tempting trade, I really love the pocky item! Is this fair, and if it isn't what would make it fair?

the pocky item's value is rather debatable.
a previous response in the is this a fair trade thread valued it at a low advent (3-4 09 rares) - I do not agree with this.
also see this successful trade where the user here valued it at an MA.
and see 200c$ for the pocky item here

I'd recommend doing some research - see here for my summary response, plus note this user's note stating that an 08 r/vr is not very realistic, so it's more of a t1 advent to an MA, which I personally agree with.

shima goes for 1-2 MAs, so I'll hesitate to say that if you value it at an MA, this is fair, but if valued at 2 MAs, they should add another MA to their side.
please get a second opinion though. you may want to ask on the "how much is this item worth?" thread for more opinions from item-versed players (:

[bunnifical]

I got a bid on my WWA auction and was wondering if I could get some help?
Thanks so much!

x

[Panda-Love-100]

would this trade be fair?
xxx

the angel wings are a current store item, worth 2.5c$ on its own
your 2014 uncommon is worth 6-7c$ on it's own, so definitely unfair to you

tysm!

[QueenSiren]

Hi it was already cancelled but was this fair? I heard that Zodiacs are worth 1-3 09 rares and I added items as extra.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92054401&userid=897504&signature=eVxx9AZXN100-yXW_nohNQ

[jutdwae]

hello, is this trade fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92054887&userid=989315&signature=Y5aYPkXjx4UHBQ06WbyzgA

[boston]

Is this a fair offer I sent? Thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92052242&userid=641753&signature=6oq6vyn0FiD_2z-3h2ygvg

[ahirked]

I got a bid on my WWA auction and was wondering if I could get some help?
Thanks so much!

x

wwa = 0.5-1 nons (source)

their side:
- 10 09 rares worth
- 2012 store = 1 MA
- 2014 store = 2 09 rares
- 2018 store = 2010 rare (0.5 09 rares)
- 2019 store = 2010 rare (0.5 09 rares)
- strawberry pps = 2 09 rares, but can go for a bit more due to demand
== 3 MAs

edit: sorry got confused with pets, unfair to you - they've only offered at most 0.25 nons

Hi it was already cancelled but was this fair? I heard that Zodiacs are worth 1-3 09 rares and I added items as extra.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92054401

zodiacs tend to go more often for 1-2 09 rares (source), although apparently there are some who value them at 3-4 09 rares (see previous source for this), which personally I disagree with.
see here for a trade where a 2014 store (2 09 rares) was swapped for a zodiac.

I would have said this is fair tbh, but maybe the user expected more/ didn't want to trade it ;;

hello, is this trade fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92054887&userid=989315&signature=Y5aYPkXjx4UHBQ06WbyzgA

cream santa dog = 1 MA
user here states that an MA = ~250c$
the 2020 store only adds about 20c$ or so to the trade, which is just under 200c$.

unfortunately I couldn't find any c$ trades for this pet, so I'd get a second opinion!

Is this a fair offer I sent? Thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92052242&userid=641753&signature=6oq6vyn0FiD_2z-3h2ygvg

arapaima seahorse = 1-1.5 MA
2018 store = 2010 rare
pink balloon = 0.5 nons (or a sorb)

seeing as the avocado goes for 1 non, this is unfair to you imo

[serenitymontaza]

is this fair?

[ahirked]

is this fair?

sunjewel = 3-4 nons, although successful trades thread more indicates 3 nons (see here)

ur zonkey = 1.5-2 nons
plains zebra = 1-1.5 nons
== 2.5-3.5 nons

depending on how the two of you value the zonkey/ zebra, I'd say it's just about fair if not under by 0.5 nons.
please get a second opinion tho jic!