The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[3ds]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92051060&userid=966372&signature=vMBRd_6v-wo94LpIHgAL9Q

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92051100&userid=966372&signature=Z4cvbvLmq18_sls3nlV5Ig ?

[kököchin]

would a blue rose be a fair 1:1 swap for a red rose with current demand? thank you for any/all responses <3

[beestie]

some folks have edited their bids, so i'd like a revaluation of the values! a quick answer would be great, please.

x / x / x

this absolutely huge bid is new too. since its mostly bulk uncommons/commons i may not consider it,
but i wanted to know if the rares made up for the bulk or vice versa.

x

and there's these two by the same person.

x / x

i'd really appreciate some help with these bids!

[Vanish]

- snip snip

this absolutely huge bid is new too. since its mostly bulk uncommons/commons i may not consider it,
but i wanted to know if the rares made up for the bulk or vice versa.

x

i'd really appreciate some help with these bids!

I can't estimate the value / fairness of the other bids, but I can tell that the bulk is very unfair to you aha.
If I've done my rough math correct, their side barely adds up to 1 2009 rare + something else, whilst your
storepets are worth multiple rares each due to being list pets - and if you don't follow the list, they're still worth
2-4 09' rares each due to being VR.

( This thread is discontinued so use with caution, but all 2012 and older storepets are lists. Their demand & cost is up to the person ,but using the old list as a guideline until a solid one places them properly is made or just clinging onto them is your best option - but this trade, eitherway, is unfair to you ! )

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91970055&userid=902320&signature=UnxEGsDU5fefp9acnxCsLg

THANK YOU FOR ANY HELP

I personally wouldn't accept this trade !

Valuing a 09' rare at 4 2010 rares (you may value at 2!), their side makes up a 3 09' rares + something.
Though the 09's would be fair for one of your pets, I personally wouldn't accept due to the pets on their side not being as highly valued(dog species), storepets(the 2014 dog) or well demanded (like the reindeer horse).

[-Explorer-]

Alas, I missed the "get on the first page quickly" rush, aha

Anyways, how's this?

Unfair to galaxy cat, their side is worth about 0.5 - 0.75 nons while the galaxy cat goes for 1 - 1.5 nons

[LemonadeQueen]

Is this fair? I’m not exactly sure what the Dogtag goes for these day.

Tysm for any help <3

[beestie]

some folks have edited their bids, so i'd like a revaluation of the values! a quick answer would be great, please.

x / x / x

and there's these two by the same person.

x / x

i'd really appreciate some help with these bids!

snip

ty! i'm aware of the list and don't quite trade by it normally, but would prefer to do so for auctions.

could i get some help with the other bids please? my auction ends today.

[Vanish]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92051060&userid=966372&signature=vMBRd_6v-wo94LpIHgAL9Q

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92051100&userid=966372&signature=Z4cvbvLmq18_sls3nlV5Ig ?

1st trade:
The dog you have is called the Blue Snowflake/Flower Advent, by this list (which I highly recommend), it is a mid advent list, which is worth 6-9 09 rares. I'd personally accept this if you're looking to go off the list (going off the list = not trading for other list pets) / some other reason !

The 3 dalmations = 3 09's
The 2020 storepets (late 10' rare) collected together = 4 09's (valuing 2 2010's at 1 09' here)
The pencil dog = 09'

So it adds up to 8 09's! - So again, I'd personally accept since it is fair to you & you'd have a lot of storepets aha.

2nd trade:
Valuing 2 2010's at 1 09 again, this is fair to you, but it does include horses & no 09's or storepets like the first,
so it's totally up to you ( which side of pets you want ) !

[Neonrift]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92051198&userid=707020&signature=VknBkhA8D5zpjysL7xxi9w anyone have any ideas on this?

[bunnifical]

I got a bid on my WWA auction and was wondering if I could get some help?
Thanks so much!

x