The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Silencer96]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92027213&userid=949781&signature=u8fKdO4q_-UdhmMy2d42Rg


Is this fair???

[~~Leafdapple~~]

Is this fair to me?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92048192&userid=1000928&signature=4bwJZaJosS190gI5AS08eA

[beestie]

some folks have edited their bids, so i'd like a revaluation of the values! a quick answer would be great, please.

x / x / x

this absolutely huge bid is new too. since its mostly bulk uncommons/commons i may not consider it,
but i wanted to know if the rares made up for the bulk or vice versa.
x

and there's these two by the same person.

x / x

i'd really appreciate some help with these bids!

[VNKP]

Got this item trade. I'm not too sure on items so any help would be great!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92036078&userid=985924&signature=RTYbGnMfIm9xG-ttn-egDA

[☽isa☾]

Is this fair to me?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92048192&userid=1000928&signature=4bwJZaJosS190gI5AS08eA

by rarity and date they would be overpaying, but butterfly wolves have lower demand so its up to you what you value more

[A Desert Rose]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92050564&userid=545189&signature=Llm-pbGe_rKG2ZpQLSrUHw

Can I get some feedback on this BEG offer, I haven't been able to get an answer elsewhere and its my leading bid at the moment. Thank you!

I counted 48-50 '09 rares using the 2=1 rule; if I miscounted please let me know lol
BEG is 1-1.5 nons which is about 100-150 '09 rares
I'd say it's kind of unfair to you, but get another opinion

Thank you!

[hellhunt]

Would that be fair (UR ice cat + BMD bunny + joker bunny for Dogtag)

[☽isa☾]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92050564&userid=545189&signature=Llm-pbGe_rKG2ZpQLSrUHw

Can I get some feedback on this BEG offer, I haven't been able to get an answer elsewhere and its my leading bid at the moment. Thank you!

I counted 48-50 '09 rares using the 2=1 rule; if I miscounted please let me know lol
BEG is 1-1.5 nons which is about 100-150 '09 rares
I'd say it's kind of unfair to you, but get another opinion

Thank you!

I was just about to write the same thing (around 50 09 rares, and the BEG is worth over 100 09 rares)

[kököchin]

would a blue rose be a fair 1:1 swap for a red rose with current demand? thank you for any/all responses <3

[beestie]

some folks have edited their bids, so i'd like a revaluation of the values! a quick answer would be great, please.

x / x / x

this absolutely huge bid is new too. since its mostly bulk uncommons/commons i may not consider it,
but i wanted to know if the rares made up for the bulk or vice versa.
x

and there's these two by the same person.

x / x

i'd really appreciate some help with these bids!