The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sycamore.]

could i have some help? I’ve been hesitating to trade my raven but this is the best trade i’ve received. thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91812268&userid=641753&signature=_1Vficp_PEO6L2S2LvYFHg

personally i think it’s a good deal. both store pets on their side have pretty good demand. patchwork goes for 1.5 nons. i’m not sure about the clockwork, but i’m sure it’s at least a non so i’d say it’s overpay. i’m not entirely sure on what the raven goes for, so you should probably get a second opinion, but i’d accept this.

raven goes fo about 2 nons, clockwork bun is worth a non, so technically it would be over pay as their side adds to 2.5 nons

I will say that lately I've been seeing the raven go for 2.5 nons, or even 3 depending on the person. Either way it's still a good offer, but I would get some more opinions!

[JustLivinTheDream]

Trade!

Is this fair???

[SussyMangos]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91811078&userid=948896&signature=tWxPHRRD-vxV5fRc3qnOBw

how is this?

[.crossfire.]

so i finally decided to auction my marshmallow/smore to see what i could get for it, can someone tell me if i rated these okay? not exactly sure the worth of the first trade, but the second is the black advent and goes for roughly a non correct? im not super good with list trades c: any help is greatly appreciated

xxxx

[Total K9]

could i have some help? I’ve been hesitating to trade my raven but this is the best trade i’ve received. thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91812268&userid=641753&signature=_1Vficp_PEO6L2S2LvYFHg

The ravendog goes for 1.5 to 2 nons, sometimes 3 due to demand. I personally think that this trade is on the edge of fair and unfair due to demand. Personally, I wouldn’t accept it becuase I think the ravendog could go for a little more. Please get another opinion!

[sycamore.]

so i finally decided to auction my marshmallow/smore to see what i could get for it, can someone tell me if i rated these okay? not exactly sure the worth of the first trade, but the second is the black advent and goes for roughly a non correct? im not super good with list trades c: any help is greatly appreciated

xxxx

yep, the black advent goes for a non!

you should definitely get another opinion, but I believe the first trade is worth more than the second trade, because the July PPS goes for a non alone.

source

[holodog]

(1) /// (2) /// (3) /// (4) /// (5)
Could I get some help with these bids for my auction? The first four are all just for the dragon cat pps but the last one is for the full dragon cat set. I'm needing help on which of these would be the highest value. Thank you very much for any assistance.

[Total K9]

so i finally decided to auction my marshmallow/smore to see what i could get for it, can someone tell me if i rated these okay? not exactly sure the worth of the first trade, but the second is the black advent and goes for roughly a non correct? im not super good with list trades c: any help is greatly appreciated

xxxx

yep, the black advent goes for a non!

you should definitely get another opinion, but I believe the first trade is worth more than the second trade, because the July PPS goes for a non alone.

source

The ur marshmallow is going to be unsteady for a little while due to it being new. Honestly, I’ve seen the marshmallow go for at least 1-2 nons. Sometimes 3.

[.crossfire.]

so i finally decided to auction my marshmallow/smore to see what i could get for it, can someone tell me if i rated these okay? not exactly sure the worth of the first trade, but the second is the black advent and goes for roughly a non correct? im not super good with list trades c: any help is greatly appreciated

xxxx

yep, the black advent goes for a non!

you should definitely get another opinion, but I believe the first trade is worth more than the second trade, because the July PPS goes for a non alone.

source

The ur marshmallow is going to be unsteady for a little while due to it being new. Honestly, I’ve seen the marshmallow go for at least 1-2 nons. Sometimes 3.

so the first one would be most fair correct? and the last bid has over 100 rares in it, but most are rats adn ponies hwich i've heard don't have a very good demand, but without demand, would it be remotely close?

edit; right after posting i recieved this, is this more than the first bid with the july pps? i know food pets dont always trade easily xxxx

[sugarbird]

Is this fair?