The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Assumed Gender]

[url]https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91771486&userid=1003578&signature=hbpVjuRjDyXxhYKC7yPbtg[/url]
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91771429&userid=1003578&signature=MBZPh3WeLRVWURdyMiFEmA

Any of these fair?

[Skull.Vincent]

How is this? and would you personally take it ?
And this one! EDIT: another one! XX Another one

@louh.i

[/quote]

For the UR Bengal, personally I would take the one offering the CEG. I'm not sure about demand, but rarity wise, the UR Bengal and CEG are both worth 1-1.5 nons. So I would just remove the VR dragon and uncommon dog and call that a fair trade.
The other offers you got have pets that I think would be difficult to trade.
Same with the one offering the flowerpot, the flowerpot is hard to trade off so I would wait for a different offer.

[WeFoundWonderland]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91772766&userid=755762&signature=8e9MECrJB3IZ_9XrJnVdyg

is this fair?

[Skull.Vincent]

Is this fair? I got this as one of the bids for my auction

The UR Kirin goes from anywhere between 1 non and 2.5 nons.
I'm unsure about the demand of the CEG, but it is worth 1-1.5 nons.
So depending on how you value your Kirin this could be a fair trade.
As far as I'm aware, the CEG trades pretty nicely and has a fair amount of demand so you shouldnt have trouble trading it.

[Skull.Vincent]

thoughts?

The UR Kirin goes for anywhere between 1-2.5 nons.
The Coontail goes for a steady 1.5-2 nons.
So depending on how you value your Kirin, this could be a fair trade.
Not sure about how well the coontail trades though. I would wait for a higher demanded pet to be offered, but its ultimately up to you.

[Pistol Annie #1 NPC]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91761640&userid=919527&signature=4gCBj4ApEuiza_qVyKABtA
help?

I’d like to know too! For reference, my rat is an omg so rare re-release from July 2008 (ex-main list), and on Lexi’s side there are four ex-Advent list pets :)

[Skull.Vincent]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91767197&userid=804805&signature=CKxEpleCoxAslq8P_jbyYQ
Fair for CEG?

No, the CEG is worth 1-1.5 nons and 1 non in C$ is at least 1500C$. This is unfair to you, they are underpaying.

Edit: 1 Non goes for anywhere between 1200-1600C$. So depending on how you value the CEG, this could be fair, but personally I would value it higher than they’re offering.

[Skull.Vincent]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91772766&userid=755762&signature=8e9MECrJB3IZ_9XrJnVdyg

is this fair?

They are overpaying, however, the UR Cucumber is extremely hard to trade off. Speaking from experience here, I would decline the offer. However, ultimately the decision is yours to make. If you dont plan on trading the Cucumber, don't worry about the demand. If you do plan on trading the Cucumber, dont accept the offer because it will be extremely hard to trade off.

[$wag23]

is this fair? Please help me out lol

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91772642&userid=837278&signature=3ZELxfH_74E3yo7SBflCZA

[Skull.Vincent]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91761640&userid=919527&signature=4gCBj4ApEuiza_qVyKABtA
help?

I’d like to know too! For reference, my rat is an omg so rare re-release from July 2008 (ex-main list), and on Lexi’s side there are four ex-Advent list pets

This would be a fair trade. Any outcome of the rat goes for 3-4 mid advents to 6-8 mid advents (0.5 non).
Depending on how the rat is valued by both parties, the other non ex-list pets could stay or be removed. Just up to you guys how you value the rat. Hope that helps!