The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[pew]

High value:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91718525&userid=901300&signature=Uc52LYaPs4FyHnN7u9VXIg
Is this fair? How much is each side worth in nons?

Please I beg you

cinnabun goes for 1.5-2 nons & zonkey goes for a solid 2, so they're side is about 3.5 nons
july pps goes for 1 non & the bee goes for 2.5-3.5, but usually the higher side of that, making your side 3.5-4.5 nons.
it depends how you value you the pets but i'd say you're better off with your pets & you'd be overpaying if you took this trade.

[hexcore]

Is This fair?
I'm honestly not sure what the UR rat goes for.
Any help is appreciated. Thank you!

Second opinion please? I'm thinking of accepting, but I just want to make sure.

Please help!! I don't want to keep them waiting

[Sori]

Is this fair? I have no idea what the pocky is worth so input would be appreciated! ^^

[teacorgi]

ALRIGHT hopefully last post abt this, would love a second opinion on this trade for my UR marshmallow !!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91713387&userid=155021&signature=MBFaXhoozpZiIYRGoPgoWw

WHOOPS I sent the wrong link, heres the right one !

[Archiy]

Is This fair?
I'm honestly not sure what the UR rat goes for.
Any help is appreciated. Thank you!

Second opinion please? I'm thinking of accepting, but I just want to make sure.

Please help!! I don't want to keep them waiting

I’m a bit rusty so this may be outdated advice, I would recommend getting a second opinion!

Starting off neither have a crazy demand so I would say they are about equal demand wise with the sitting cat having more of a demand. Valuing the UR grapes at a sorb and the rats at less than a sorb and the tier 5 cat together don’t equal the grapes. I would say they would need to add to make it fairer and close the small gap in between the UR grapes and rat. Probably 1-2 MAs. Again I would get a second opinion but I hope this helps!

[pochita]

High value:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91718525&userid=901300&signature=Uc52LYaPs4FyHnN7u9VXIg
Is this fair? How much is each side worth in nons?

Please I beg you

[pew]

Not sure what the spotted tribal goes for, would this be fair?
Thanks for any help

the tribal goes for .5 non or 1 sorb, which is 5-7 mid advents worth. the red rose goes for 2-4 mid advents each based off of this & my own experience. their side adds up to 4-8 mid advents depending how you value them. I'd say it's pretty fair & if anything, just slightly unfair to their side.

Is this fair? I have no idea what the pocky is worth so input would be appreciated! ^^

i haven't seen a lot of info on the pocky's worth recently but i think they can trade anywhere between an 08 VR - a mid advent (somebody correct me if i'm wrong, just using my own experience and the very little info i've found). either way, their store pet is only worth a mid advent pet, maybe a little bit more. so that or the pocky for your bun would be fair alone. but with the box/cake dog makes it unfair on your side.

so i'd say if you value items high, the store pet + pocky would maybe be fair for the cake dog/box (although I think you'd be better off with your cake dog). or the pocky alone or store pet alone would be fine for the dog tag bunny.

and the 2013 rare is overpay for the 2 bats.

[Oblivion.]

Hello, how are these trades?
One
Two
Thank you

[sycamore.]

Can I get some help with this trade and this trade for my UR Cat?

And this trade? (15 horsehair wigs, 2 anniversary bows, balloon lion plush, 2 rainbow tess birthday signs, 2 horse/wolf figurines, and more for my flop-eared pink september)

Also, was this trade fair? Thank you so much for any help!

I don't want to keep them waiting, so I'd really appreciate any response, thank you! <3

[Scaled and Icy]

I'm not great with bulk item trades, so does this seem fair?