The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Bastiodon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91525904&userid=839319&signature=ca8TqjfjZ76S9xL4XqGwSw

hows this look? i dont know what any of the pets are worth or what they go for

[.crossfire.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91525628&userid=729040&signature=ekIYJ4_j9S-_U6HEY_tUbg
would this be fair? neither me or my trading partner are sure so i figured i would ask

Pineapple = non
Angel Advent = roughly 3 mid advents

Their side:
Roughly 10-10.5 mid advents (6 T7 dogs, fairy goat = 1 mid advent, seahorse = 1.5-2 mid advents, both ex T1 advents go for 3-4 09 rares each, malk cat = 4 09 rares).

Nons are 10-12 mid advents. If you value at 10.5 or less, the pineapple alone would be enough. If valued at 10.5+, they'd need to add. Demand is quantity is up to you and your trading partner.

thank you, second opinion please?

[Highland]

Is this fair??? I know rarity wise it’s beyond fair, what about demand wise?

[Brackensnake]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91525856&userid=781035&signature=ZHoUlNZAW9ZVLC-IvHSyQA

[.crossfire.]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91525856&userid=781035&signature=ZHoUlNZAW9ZVLC-IvHSyQA

i belives they are overpaying. if you do the 2:1 ratio then your side would be a 2017 rare + 2020 rare, so just the rare on their side would be enough.. but get a second opinion

[♥Princess of Lions♥]

Is this a fair trade in demand? Thanks for who ever answers! :) trades/viewtrade.php?id=91503327&userid=662370&signature=sZEEOyqn0gLah93tQTk38g

[Southern sweetie]

Is this fair ?
link

[kjzq]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91525904&userid=839319&signature=ca8TqjfjZ76S9xL4XqGwSw

hows this look? i dont know what any of the pets are worth or what they go for

Joker = 1-1.5 nons
Butterbun = 1 non
Speckled Rat = .25-.5 nons (usually goes for .25)

While it technically could be fair/overpay, I personally wouldn't accept because both pets on their side don't have the best demand in comparison to the joker, which has pretty good demand.

[BB-8]

So I'm not good with differences in years when trading though it seems pretty fair overall? Any help is greatly appreciated.

My side has the PPS

Thanks

[.crossfire.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91525628&userid=729040&signature=ekIYJ4_j9S-_U6HEY_tUbg
would this be fair? neither me or my trading partner are sure so i figured i would ask

Pineapple = non
Angel Advent = roughly 3 mid advents

Their side:
Roughly 10-10.5 mid advents (6 T7 dogs, fairy goat = 1 mid advent, seahorse = 1.5-2 mid advents, both ex T1 advents go for 3-4 09 rares each, malk cat = 4 09 rares).

Nons are 10-12 mid advents. If you value at 10.5 or less, the pineapple alone would be enough. If valued at 10.5+, they'd need to add. Demand is quantity is up to you and your trading partner.

thank you, second opinion please?