The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Redbird]

Yooo, anyone know if this is fair?? I'm not sure how much the Target dog is worth smh,, trades/viewtrade.php?id=91468880&userid=911581&signature=CB_RaX3LIVJQtHGXzSAi_Q

Target dog is worth 1.5-2 mid advents. This doesn't look fair to you, but if someone with more experience in C$ wants to come in and share their opinion, that would be great!

[.crossfire.]

Yooo, anyone know if this is fair?? I'm not sure how much the Target dog is worth smh,, trades/viewtrade.php?id=91468880&userid=911581&signature=CB_RaX3LIVJQtHGXzSAi_Q

Target dog is worth 1.5-2 mid advents. This doesn't look fair to you, but if someone with more experience in C$ wants to come in and share their opinion, that would be great!

c$ wise, the target is worth 160-180 c$ (as stated here but I personally wouldn't trade an ex-list for c$ only because i find it much harder to get another back with c$. however, it is up to you and your trading partner. i would also get another opinion

[Angelhearth]

Yooo, anyone know if this is fair?? I'm not sure how much the Target dog is worth smh,, trades/viewtrade.php?id=91468880&userid=911581&signature=CB_RaX3LIVJQtHGXzSAi_Q

Target dog is worth 1.5-2 mid advents. This doesn't look fair to you, but if someone with more experience in C$ wants to come in and share their opinion, that would be great!

c$ wise, the target is worth 160-180 c$ (as stated here but I personally wouldn't trade an ex-list for c$ only because i find it much harder to get another back with c$. however, it is up to you and your trading partner. i would also get another opinion

Please don’t use those C$ values they are old!
More recent C$ trade involving a target dog Click here!
It went for 350 in that trade, so I would agree with Redbird that it doesn’t look fair to you, however it’s always a bit hard to translate quantity lower quality pets into C$.

[Flicka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91418790&userid=9355&signature=WWoWHd-YUDQkK0AwoOfv5g is this fair?

their side= 12 '09 rares, i think the eggs and balloons are worth an 09 rare each and the stocking worth an 09 uncommon?
your side=8 09 rares
it's slight overpay or fair because i'm not 100% on the items and idk what kind of demand the sitting cats have

Help?

[Redbird]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91418790&userid=9355&signature=WWoWHd-YUDQkK0AwoOfv5g is this fair?

their side= 12 '09 rares, i think the eggs and balloons are worth an 09 rare each and the stocking worth an 09 uncommon?
your side=8 09 rares
it's slight overpay or fair because i'm not 100% on the items and idk what kind of demand the sitting cats have

Help?

I responded to this on the last page!

[♥Princess of Lions♥]

Is this a fair trade in demand? Thanks for who ever answers! :) trades/viewtrade.php?id=91503327&userid=662370&signature=sZEEOyqn0gLah93tQTk38g

[.crossfire.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91525628&userid=729040&signature=ekIYJ4_j9S-_U6HEY_tUbg
would this be fair? neither me or my trading partner are sure so i figured i would ask

[CloudedJasper]

I know its a pretty simply trade, but is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91525674&userid=856554&signature=xh1jI9hcidrcPKtsw9ZOSg

[Angelhearth]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91418790&userid=9355&signature=WWoWHd-YUDQkK0AwoOfv5g is this fair?

their side= 12 '09 rares, i think the eggs and balloons are worth an 09 rare each and the stocking worth an 09 uncommon?
your side=8 09 rares
it's slight overpay or fair because i'm not 100% on the items and idk what kind of demand the sitting cats have

I responded to this on the last page!

You said on the last page that you disagree about the eggs worth, those are established trading values though. If you count the eggs at a late 2009 rare each(look at the item guide, it’s a bit out of date(March 2019), but items don’t get rereleased as far as I know, so they likely gain value) then their side is worth 12 ‘09 rares plus two items I’m unsure about.

Your side is worth 8 ‘09 rares, as bugbaby already said.I’m not aware of any specific demand for your pets other than the usual sitting cat demand. Tess horses generally have good demand as well, so that shouldn’t be an issue.

[_Korat_]

i canceled this trade thinking it was way unfair to me and i just wanna check im right in thinking that?