The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[bugbaby]

Boop 1 :]
Boop 2 :]
Are these trades fair?
Thank you for the help, in advance! ^-^

1 - the sunback cat is just a normal 09 vr, sitting cats sometimes get more so 2-3 09 rares. the vr malk egg and bat are worth an '09 rare together, the other pets (not sure about the items but I know the shamrock balloon is from 2010) reasonably adds up to another or just under another '09 rare so I would say fair
2 - their side is worth a little over 3 '09 rares (valuing the '08 dog at an '09 because i think it was an extended release?) so fair or slight over.
if you are deciding between the two trades i think i prefer the second one just because i'm more sure about the value and it has a store pet with pretty good demand in it

Is this fair?

each dog from your side is an ma each, the target dog is worth 1.5-2 but i don't know exactly what it goes for, it's probably a little under to you though as i don't think the target dog has any outstanding demand? may want a second opinion

This? Told them I'd rather trade for store pets than C$ and they sent this over. I haven't seen many people willing to sell lists for C$ and even then they seem like really high prices so not sure if this is fair or I could get the same value back.

Looking for second opinion on this one ^

i think the blue scarf dog is worth about 100 c$ according to this so i believe they might already be overpaying just in c$

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91501781&userid=75661&signature=9_EjQCrnfS5TrXTNIcKP8A

advice please, also this? Is it fair, if not how could it be made fair? Thanks
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91518993&userid=75661&signature=o1V1GuN8xymAUAj9S9odkg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91517142&userid=75661&signature=3PspVzHZHpgVvVjohnEDWA

2nd trade: also unfair to you, their side is worth a little over 1 '12 rare
3rd trade: your side is worth 8-9 09 rares, theirs is worth the same (5 09 rares + scarf dog which is 3-4 09 rares) so fair

-snip-



Really helped! Tysm!
Also that?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90016938&userid=994729&signature=eflaAOCg6JNoLDx2x3qixA

their side is worth 6-7 ma's, the rose pps is worth 3-4 so they are over (green toxic alone is worth 3-4 but the rose pps has better demand I think)

I got this trade and I was wondering if it was fair? I’m unfamiliar with C$‘s ): The C$ worth thread said the rat is worth about ~490 C$

500 c$ is pretty standard for most omgsr rats, so that offer is usually what it goes for
sorry for long post ^^

[moondance.]

can i please get someone's thoughts? it's been two days already i don't want to take too long to respond!!

hi! could someone please look over this trade for me?
i'm not sure what my pet is worth but i think it was a tier 7 list, and i'm not sure what their side is worth in relation to mine!
any tips/thoughts are appreciated<3

[bugbaby]

can i please get someone's thoughts? it's been two days already i don't want to take too long to respond!!

hi! could someone please look over this trade for me?
i'm not sure what my pet is worth but i think it was a tier 7 list, and i'm not sure what their side is worth in relation to mine!
any tips/thoughts are appreciated<3

most t7 list dogs are worth 1 ma or 7-8 '09 rares 😀
the pets on their side add up to about 5 '09 rares, i think the teddy goes for an '09 rare because plushies are popular and the rest go for an '09 uncommon each, so the items are worth 4 '09 rares in total. it's fair but i don't know the item worths exactly

[Horsesrule5000]

Is this fair?

[.crossfire.]

would the ur pineapple be fair for the ur banana? if now what is the gap between the two, including demand (i understand that demand is user based, but i know the pineapple doesn’t have the best demand and goes for less than it is worth)

any help is greatly appreciated

[kate,]

This one is for my BA, ignoring the C$. How much does the hun actually go for? C$ and random lists that aren’t high in demand I know are harder to trade so idk about this offer
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91519621&userid=830519&signature=-yihf4SBkgKk1yY_3DU1Nw

[12th]

Hi there! I need some help with this trade.
I'm not sure about demand wise... I'd appreciate the help! <3

[Yoshikage]

Would one of these pets be fair for the
2015 horse or pps wolf dragon set storepets?

Sorry, I'm bad at rarities haha.

[himarry 124]

This one is for my BA, ignoring the C$. How much does the hun actually go for? C$ and random lists that aren’t high in demand I know are harder to trade so idk about this offer
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91519621&userid=830519&signature=-yihf4SBkgKk1yY_3DU1Nw

the joker bun is worth a non so they are offering you about 2 nons for the BA and your ba isent even true date that is a really good offer

[skunkiii]

hi is this trade fair?